vilagai

✓ 56 sourced quotes

Ranked by evidence

5 Best Bread Machines of 2026, Ranked by Owner Reviews

Published

Oh my gosh. I didn’t even post an update! The Zojirushi is a dream machine. I have made four different breads and a batch of rolls so far. They were all perfect. It is worth every penny and then some. There is a reason why it is three times the price. Hubby calls it Godzilla due to the size and weight. I call it the best purchase I made in a long time.— Reddit comment · u/jnortond · r/Breadit · 2022-11-29 · on the #1 pick, Zojirushi Virtuoso Plus

  1. 1 Zojirushi Virtuoso PlusBest overall 16 sources
  2. 2 Panasonic SD-YR2550Most proven 12 sources
  3. 3 Cuisinart CBK-200Most divisive 10 sources
  4. 4 Breville Custom LoafMost customizable 9 sources
  5. 5 Hamilton Beach HomeBakerBest value 9 sources
1
Best overall

Zojirushi Virtuoso Plus

BB-PDC20BA (black) / BB-PDC20WH (white)

Illustration of Zojirushi Virtuoso Plus Illustration of the product
Zojirushi Virtuoso Plus — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Loaf Size Range
2 lb only
Owner-Reported Lifespan
15 to 25+ years, still baking weekly

Why it ranks here. Ask any bread forum which machine to buy and this is the answer, usually followed by someone posting that theirs is twenty years old and still works perfectly. The dual paddles and heated lid give the most even, best-browned loaf of any machine here, a recent buyer from a cheaper Cuisinart says it is worth every penny and then some, and owners use it for pizza dough, bao buns, brioche and sourdough starter.

It is the most expensive machine here and only bakes a two-pound loaf. The trap is the two kneading paddles: if they are not lined up before you start the loaf comes out lopsided, and several owners baked crooked bread for years before a comment section told them why, because the manual does not warn you.

What owners like

  • Twenty years of regular use
  • Most even, best-browned loaf
  • Dough, pizza, jam and starter

What owners complain about

  • Most expensive, two-pound loaf only
  • Misaligned paddles bake lopsided

Oh my gosh. I didn’t even post an update! The Zojirushi is a dream machine. I have made four different breads and a batch of rolls so far. They were all perfect. It is worth every penny and then some. There is a reason why it is three times the price. Hubby calls it Godzilla due to the size and weight. I call it the best purchase I made in a long time.— Reddit comment · u/jnortond · r/Breadit · 2022-11-29

14 positive · 2 mixed · 16 voices · ✓ all 16 linked to source

Read all 16 quotes (16 voices)
  • I don’t have any complaints, other than maybe the worn out pan. Could replace that for $20 but haven’t bothered as it still works. It’s made the same bread the same way for over 20 years now! It’ll do fancier stuff like brioche as it has a cycle programmed in to let you add stuff like butter and eggs between kneading and rising. I usually just use it for sandwich bread, though.

    Reddit comment · u/DerpMaster2 · r/BuyItForLife · 2025-06-27 · read the original ↗

  • I have a Zojirushi virtuoso and love it. Don't like the sourdough recipes in the book so it took some trial and error to make a custom program for it. Pros: I make *all* the bread my family eats now. Cons: I never make boules anymore

    Reddit comment · u/babygrenade · r/Breadit · 2024-03-23 · read the original ↗

  • Oh my gosh. I didn’t even post an update! The Zojirushi is a dream machine. I have made four different breads and a batch of rolls so far. They were all perfect. It is worth every penny and then some. There is a reason why it is three times the price. Hubby calls it Godzilla due to the size and weight. I call it the best purchase I made in a long time.

    Reddit comment · u/jnortond · r/Breadit · 2022-11-29 · read the original ↗

  • Thank you for the blade tip- I was getting lopsided bread and didn't know why.

    YouTube comment · @SusanASteberBrokerAssociate · 2018-11-17 · watch the original ↗

  • Have had my virtuoso for several years and never knew about the paddle orientation. My loaves mostly were lopsided but I lived with it. Great review😊

    YouTube comment · @carolynhogan4774 · 2018-11-17 · watch the original ↗

  • The Zojirushi Breadmaker produces a mammoth size loaf of delicious bread. To maximize every last crumb I have a routine.

    YouTube comment · @trishfitzpatrick2066 · 2018-11-17 · watch the original ↗

  • I bought my Zojirushi bread machine from Craig List. I LOVE IT! We use it a lot.

    YouTube comment · @godisgoodallthetime7622 · 2018-11-17 · watch the original ↗

  • My zojirushi virtuoso plus is the beast of a machine! It makes a perfect loaf of bread every time!

    YouTube comment · @3rd-Wave_Rebel · 2018-10-25 · watch the original ↗

  • In a fit of rage I bought the big zojirushi a couple years ago. I only use it, on average, probably once a week, but having a bread maker in general has been great. Pizza dough, organic white bread, dough for bao buns, it makes it all great.

    YouTube comment · @rre9121 · 2026-05-13 · watch the original ↗

  • My Zojirushi is 18 years old and still works perfectly. I use it a few times a month. I use it for mixing and proofing dough. I love it.

    Reddit comment · u/larkinowl · r/BuyItForLife · 2024-01-24 · read the original ↗

  • Zojirushi- I got 2 from thrift store, less than $25 for both.

    Reddit comment · u/fifichanx · r/BuyItForLife · 2024-01-24 · read the original ↗

  • Zojirushi bread is really really good! I had some tonight with stew. Looks like you have the same mini loaf one I do. I still make pizza dough, and boules, and italian loaves, but this is the go to for sandwich bread.

    Reddit comment · u/gibbonsgerg · r/Breadit · 2024-03-23 · read the original ↗

  • I bought mine a month ago. It is one of life’s simple pleasures, and so satisfying to make food and really know what’s gone into it. And far easier than I’d imagined—especially if you bake by weight (put the bin on the scale, tare, add the first ingredient, tare again, etc etc. it’s far easier and less messy than having measuring cups, levelling them off, the excess spills somewhere, etc—all of which is very simple and yet produces just a bit of a mess each time.

    YouTube comment · @jpp7783 · 2018-11-17 · watch the original ↗

  • I love my Zojirushi Virtuoso machine. One thought/tip: to release the pan from the machine, grab both handles and pull towards you/the front of the machine. It releases much easier than pulling straight up!

    YouTube comment · @marylg603 · 2018-11-17 · watch the original ↗

  • We love our Virtuoso and have been on a spree because we bought 4 drums of wheat berries at 40 lbs each so we bake at least 2 loaves per day. I really appreciate the tip about lining up the blades so the loaves don't come out lopsided. We had no recourse to that. Thanks so much!

    YouTube comment · @justaperson7130 · 2018-11-17 · watch the original ↗

  • This bread maker gets used a lot more often than I initially thought it would. I most often use it to make doughs, for pizza, pasta and other baked goods. It's also helped me with sourdough starter and can make jam (though I haven't tried that yet).

    YouTube review · all day i eat like a shark · 2018-11-17 · watch the original ↗

2
Most proven

Panasonic SD-YR2550

SD-YR2550, SD-ZB2502, and the older SD-2500/SD-3500 family

Illustration of Panasonic SD-YR2550 Illustration of the product
Panasonic SD-YR2550 — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Loaf Size Range
Not stated
Owner-Reported Lifespan
20 to 30 years, thousands of loaves

Why it ranks here. The machine that turns up in every thread asking how long a bread machine lasts, with numbers that sound made up: one owner wore one out only after twenty years of constant use, another is at 21 years and over three thousand loaves, a third's is almost thirty. It is the default outside North America, it beat a cheap rival on rise and crumb in an owner's side-by-side bake, and its deep program list from pizza dough to brioche to jam actually gets used.

The non-stick pan is the weak spot: one owner went through two machines whose pans scuffed within weeks, and a replacement pan costs close to half a new machine. Another owner's pan has made over a thousand loaves and still looks new, with one trick: never wash it, just brush out the dried crumbs.

What owners like

  • Twenty to thirty years
  • Better rise and crumb than cheap machines
  • Programs owners actually use

What owners complain about

  • Pan can scuff early
  • Replacement pan is half a machine

I've been making bread with a Panasonic machine since 1998. Best machines ever made. I did manage to wear one out after 20 years of constant use.— YouTube comment · @alanshaw598 · 2026-05-13

11 positive · 1 negative · 12 voices · ✓ all 12 linked to source

Read all 12 quotes (12 voices)
  • I don't have an oven so use a breadmaker. I bought a Panasonic at the local thrift store and so far have around 500 loaves through it. It is said that the Panasonic will last around 2 years, I have had mine 7 so far.

    YouTube comment · @terrancewilhite9260 · 2018-10-25 · watch the original ↗

  • I've been making bread with a Panasonic machine since 1998. Best machines ever made. I did manage to wear one out after 20 years of constant use.

    YouTube comment · @alanshaw598 · 2026-05-13 · watch the original ↗

  • We bought our first bread maker around 2010. We had moved into a new area and didn't like the bread on offer. The first one broke down while I was at work. I came home to discover he had already ordered a new one online....there was no question of going back to sliced bread! My old Panasonic is still on my counter and still doing nicely.

    YouTube comment · @ClaireGodson-mf7rn · 2026-05-13 · watch the original ↗

  • Our Panasonic breadmaker is almost 30.

    Reddit comment · u/ragnarok62 · r/BuyItForLife · 2023-01-06 · read the original ↗

  • Mine is 21 years and used 3 times per week so over 3000 loaves so far.

    Reddit comment · u/jakethepeg111 · r/BuyItForLife · 2023-01-06 · read the original ↗

  • My Panasonic pan has made over 1000 loaves and still looks like new. The secret is to never wash it. Even when just making dough, the crumbs will just dry up and brush out with a towel.

    Reddit comment · u/__g_e_o_r_g_e__ · r/BuyItForLife · 2023-01-06 · read the original ↗

  • I have a Panasonic breed machine and I live by its bread recipes that came in the manual, they've been flawless for me. I use a 6 seed wholemeal flower from Kent and it makes the best best ever.

    Reddit comment · u/alias_neo · r/BuyItForLife · 2023-01-06 · read the original ↗

  • Ours is a Panasonic I think, must have made a couple thousands loaves of bread by now I should think if not more. Still going strong. Save money and have much better bread then the crap you get at Tesco and other supermarkets.

    Reddit comment · u/kuddlesworth9419 · r/BuyItForLife · 2024-01-24 · read the original ↗

  • I've had two Panasonic and they do make great bread, however, the pans scuffed. One lasted six months and the other two weeks. There have been many reports of this, I'm not sure if it poses a health risk but they should be more durable considering the higher price.

    Reddit comment · u/LeoInSpace · r/BreadMachines · 2026-04-12 · read the original ↗

  • I have had a few cheapy bread machines over the years… I've had issues or they've failed over time but the Panasonic SD-ZB2502 I have now (which I got second around 6 years ago) has lasted well and I'm happy to recommend. The pan is a great size, the variety of settings for different types of breads is great, it has a variety of dough settings (including pizza, french bread, fortified dough and brioche), a tray for automatically adding additional ingredients (seeds/fruit), it can make jams/compotes, cakes, has a long delayed timer for overnight baking…. All together, it is definitely the best bread machine I've had.

    Reddit comment · u/StillJustJones · r/BreadMachines · 2026-04-12 · read the original ↗

  • As you can see in the photo, the loaf from the Panasonic rose beautifully. The crust was nice and crispy and the inside was incredibly soft and fluffy. The loaf from my Neretva didn't rise nearly as much and the crumb was a little bit denser. Until today, I thought that was just how bread turned out. After using the Panasonic, I don't think I can go back to my Neretva!

    Reddit post · u/mycatsaresleeping · r/BreadMachines · 2026-07-27 · read the original ↗

  • Six months on, I'm sharing my long-term review, having tested out the majority of its 32 programs. This video shows how versatile this bread-making machine is for daily use, including kneading dough and various baking tasks.

    YouTube review · Candid Clara · 2026-05-13 · watch the original ↗

3
Most divisive

Cuisinart CBK-200

CBK-200 and the newer CBK-210

Illustration of Cuisinart CBK-200 Illustration of the product
Cuisinart CBK-200 — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Loaf Size Range
1 to 2 lb
Owner-Reported Lifespan
Mixed; pan and quality issues within months for some

Why it ranks here. The machine most first-time buyers weigh against the Zojirushi, at half the price with a convection fan, and common at thrift stores for very little. Owners who weigh ingredients instead of using cups and run only the dough cycle get consistently good bread, and one Goodwill find baked a perfect whole wheat loaf.

America's Test Kitchen rated it lowest of the machines it tried, citing inconsistent bakes, a sunken top and a lid that gets hot. Owners who bake in the machine report rock-hard or undercooked loaves with no way to add bake time, and one made a horrible buzzing noise mid-bake. A twelve-year Cuisinart owner called the new version cheaply made and returned it for a Zojirushi.

What owners like

  • Half the premium price
  • Good bread on the dough cycle

What owners complain about

  • Rated lowest by the test kitchen
  • Bricks or underbaked loaves
  • Cheaply made new version

I just purchased the 200 and made my first honey whole wheat loaf- which turned out PERFECT!!! Yeah!! so happy- why do you ask? Because I bought it at the Goodwill for $9.00 dollars!! I took the risk that it would work and it did!!— YouTube comment · @donna4010 · 2017-09-15

2 positive · 2 mixed · 6 negative · 10 voices · ✓ all 10 linked to source

Read all 10 quotes (10 voices)
  • This bread machine sported an easy-to-understand (if a bit dim) display screen, and we also liked the handles on the outside of the machine, which made for easy maneuvering for storage purposes. However, the metal exterior and the lid heated up significantly during baking, making it hot to touch when opening the machine and removing the bread. It was also rather loud when kneading, and the results were inconsistent; sometimes a decent loaf with an even crust emerged, but other times the top of the bread was sunken in and the crumb was too light and feathery, falling apart when cut. We also had issues with the bread pan handle being too close to the top of the bread pan—on more than one occasion, it baked into the crust.

    Reddit comment · u/thatoneovader (quoting America's Test Kitchen) · r/Breadit · 2022-11-03 · read the original ↗

  • I bought the Cuisinart after having a beloved Cuisinart bread maker for the last 12 years. The pan broke and a replacement pan was going to be $50. Knowing how long things tend to last, I didn’t want to spend $50 in vain. Hate, hate, hate the new machine. It’s made incredibly cheap and it’s going back. Plus, I don’t want skyscraper bread. Bought the Zojirushi Virtuoso Plus. I have my first bread in it as we speak. I will let you know how it goes.

    Reddit comment · u/jnortond · r/Breadit · 2022-11-06 · read the original ↗

  • Tried making my first loaf with the Cuisinart bread maker using the white bread recipe from their website… honestly don’t know what went wrong. It came out hard as a rock and was basically inedible. Also, didn’t realize I had to remove the paddle, so that baked into the bottom

    Reddit post · u/Top_Place381 · r/Breadit · 2025-04-14 · read the original ↗

  • I also have the cuisinart bread maker and to be honest I have not made good bread in it. I will use the machine regularly to knead and proof my dough. Put it on setting #7 (I think) for dough, once it finishes the kneading and rising I will take it out shape it and plop it into a bread pan/ shape into rolls and bake in the oven. Perfect bread!!

    Reddit comment · u/muffetbakes · r/Breadit · 2025-04-14 · read the original ↗

  • I have never had much luck using the bread machine to bake bread, I much prefer to use it as a kneading and proofing machine.

    Reddit comment · u/fantompiper · r/Breadit · 2025-04-15 · read the original ↗

  • Set a timer for 83 minutes after you start. You should hear the last kneading and a beep at about that time. Then it is time to pull out the dough, remove the paddle, make the dough into a nice shape, and return to the machine to continue. 300 grams Bread flour (I've been using King Arthur), 2 grams salt, 8 grams powdered non-fat milk, 18 grams sugar, 25 grams softened butter, 3 grams yeast, 185 grams of water. Set for 1 lb loaf, light bake. ...this recipe and checking yields some consistently decent white sandwich bread for me and my family with my Cuisinart. And as others have said, get a scale and measure out things by weight. You will get much more consistent and repeatable results from your baking.

    Reddit comment · u/KinderGameMichi · r/Breadit · 2025-04-15 · read the original ↗

  • Every time I make bread in my bread maker it is just barely not cooked enough. I do not see a way to just increase the bake time by a few minutes anywhere. Is that a thing or is mine going to make slightly undercooked bread forever?

    Reddit post · u/GiggleGuy08 · r/Breadit · 2022-11-12 · read the original ↗

  • Hey! I just tried to make a gluten free loaf in my new Cuisinart CBK 200. During the bake cycle, it made a horrible buzzing noise that stopped abruptly after a few minutes. Anybody have experience with this? Thanks in advance!

    Reddit post · u/Stumpadoodlepoo · r/Breadit · 2018-02-24 · read the original ↗

  • I just purchased the 200 and made my first honey whole wheat loaf- which turned out PERFECT!!! Yeah!! so happy- why do you ask? Because I bought it at the Goodwill for $9.00 dollars!! I took the risk that it would work and it did!!

    YouTube comment · @donna4010 · 2017-09-15 · watch the original ↗

  • I've had my Cuisinart Bread Machine for 2 years and I've made 50-60 loaves. Find out what I like, dislike, and whether it's even worth buying.

    YouTube review · Kevin Stratvert · 2017-09-15 · watch the original ↗

4
Most customizable

Breville Custom Loaf

BBM800XL

Illustration of Breville Custom Loaf Illustration of the product
Breville Custom Loaf — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Loaf Size Range
1 to 2.5 lb
Owner-Reported Lifespan
Not stated

Why it ranks here. The machine for people who want to program their own knead, rise and bake times and have fruit and nuts dropped in automatically at the right moment. It bakes anything from one to two and a half pounds, and owners of both say it beats the Zojirushi on flexibility.

It costs as much as the Zojirushi, which is built like a truck and runs quieter by the same owners' account, or as much as a stand mixer, which one commenter says to buy instead. It has a reputation for walking across the counter on heavy doughs, though not every owner sees it. The collapsible paddle does not always fold, leaving it baked upright into the loaf with a big hole to rip out. Thrift-store finds change the maths entirely.

What owners like

  • Automatic add-in dispenser
  • Custom programs
  • Widest loaf range

What owners complain about

  • Walks on heavy dough
  • Paddle fails to collapse
  • Stand-mixer money

I have both machines and each one is built to be sturdy and strong. The "add-in" dispenser is very nice and convenient on the Breville. It works well and allows you to be "untied" to the bread machine since it works automatically. The Breville offers lots of options and possibilities. It is designed to make several different size loaves of bread. The Zoj is a completely different device! ... It's heavy and sturdy and built like a truck! ... I lean towards the Zoj due to it's heavier construction. If I'm making a "nut/seed/fruit bread" I usually use the Breville. ... Both of my machines were purchased at local thrift stores and cost less than $20.00.— Reddit comment · u/kd4pxq · r/BreadMachines · 2025-09-25

2 positive · 3 mixed · 2 neutral · 2 negative · 9 voices · ✓ all 9 linked to source

Read all 9 quotes (9 voices)
  • Zojirushi is much quieter. Breville has a reputation of walking off counter while kneading heavy doughs but has add-in dispenser :)

    Reddit comment · u/Kittychance · r/BreadMachines · 2025-09-22 · read the original ↗

  • I’ve had the Breville for about eight months and it’s not moved a millimeter. I was worried when I read some reviews, but mine is sturdy and does the job (though, not sure it’s worth all the unused bells and whistles).

    Reddit comment · u/Educational_Joke1754 · r/BreadMachines · 2025-09-25 · read the original ↗

  • I have both machines and each one is built to be sturdy and strong. The "add-in" dispenser is very nice and convenient on the Breville. It works well and allows you to be "untied" to the bread machine since it works automatically. The Breville offers lots of options and possibilities. It is designed to make several different size loaves of bread. The Zoj is a completely different device! ... It's heavy and sturdy and built like a truck! ... I lean towards the Zoj due to it's heavier construction. If I'm making a "nut/seed/fruit bread" I usually use the Breville. ... Both of my machines were purchased at local thrift stores and cost less than $20.00.

    Reddit comment · u/kd4pxq · r/BreadMachines · 2025-09-25 · read the original ↗

  • I have a Breville Custom Loaf that I'm enjoying so far. I bought it new about 2 months ago. It has a folding paddle that I thought was supposed to automatically fold down flat-ish when mixing is done so it doesn't leave a giant hole at the bottom of the loaf. But after 10+ loads of different kinds it has never folded down. It bakes into the bottom still in it's upright position, sticks like crazy and the only way to remove the bread from the pan is to rip a giant hole.

    Reddit post · u/steady_downpour · r/BreadMachines · 2026-01-17 · read the original ↗

  • Outback Steakhouse copycat - recipe second photo. I've done this multiple times as it's a fave. Baked as per recipe except I add 1/2 tbsp of instant coffee, and 1 1/2 tbsp of Fleischman's Booster plus a tbsp of vital wheat gluten to the flour. Also, I always take the paddle out before the bake. ... Loaf weighs 960g. No crumb photo as this loaf is being gifted.

    Reddit post · u/Kelvinator_61 · r/BreadMachines · 2026-08-21 · read the original ↗

  • 10:34 If you are willing to pay 250USD for a basic loaf of bread, then purchase a stand mixer. It'll provide better end product and you can use it for 10x more recipes.

    YouTube comment · @Apocalypz · 2018-10-25 · watch the original ↗

  • I started out with bread machines, and most make a good loaf. The collapsed top is a characteristic of many of them, and I usually sue the french dark setting as the best way to get a tasty loaf. I progressed to Kitchenaid and hand, and they will always take some beating. That Breville looks like it does a good job, Breville is a good brand.

    YouTube comment · @scottmcginn2169 · 2018-10-25 · watch the original ↗

  • That Breville is $400 now. Just found one for $35 at goodwill. Hoping it works well. 🤘

    YouTube comment · @lowbudgetstunts3423 · 2018-10-25 · watch the original ↗

  • On today's episode of Kitchen Gadgets, Esther is joined by Sim Cass to test out bread making machines.

    YouTube review · Eater · 2018-10-25 · watch the original ↗

5
Best value

Hamilton Beach HomeBaker

29881 / 29882 / 29888

Illustration of Hamilton Beach HomeBaker Illustration of the product
Hamilton Beach HomeBaker — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Loaf Size Range
1.5 to 2 lb
Owner-Reported Lifespan
A budget buy, not a decades-long keeper

Why it ranks here. The machine people buy to find out whether they will actually use a bread machine: very cheap new, a few dollars at Goodwill, and most owners get a decent basic loaf plus dough, jam and cake cycles. One rates the bread mode ten out of ten.

Nearly every owner has a story about the noise, the walking or the paddle hole. One needs a bag of flour behind it and something heavy in front to stop it throwing itself off the counter, another says the manual's recipes always over-rise and push the lid open, and the large paddle hole drives a regular user mad. One new unit stalled mid-knead on its second loaf. A fair way to find out whether you want bread at home, not a keeper.

What owners like

  • Very cheap
  • Decent basic loaf

What owners complain about

  • Loud, walks off the counter
  • Recipes over-proof
  • Large paddle hole

I have recently returned to using my hamilton beach horizontal bread maker. It makes great basic bread . I usually use the 1 1/2 lb size which is just right for my husband and me. But the damn large paddle hole is driving me mad.— Reddit post · u/Melsm1957 · r/BreadMachines · 2024-07-30

4 positive · 2 mixed · 3 negative · 9 voices · ✓ all 9 linked to source

Read all 9 quotes (9 voices)
  • I have had this for a couple of years. Works Great : Hamilton Beach Bread Maker Machine #

    Reddit comment · u/China_Hawk · r/BuyItForLife · 2025-01-12 · read the original ↗

  • Thanks for the review and tips. I had no idea they were noisy and that they can walk off the counter. Your review helped me decide which brand to get.

    YouTube comment · @Alienwordz · 2014-12-14 · watch the original ↗

  • I got my Hamilton Beach Bread machine yesterday...I thought the machine was actually pretty quiet and I don't mind the size; I didn't think it was overly big. Works for me!...Mine doesn't seem to "walk" across the counter either. ... The bread was wonderful - tasty and filling. It didn't rise as much as I wanted, but gluten-free breads don't always "grow" like the regular breads. The paddle didn't stick in my bread...it fell right out! Yay! I toasted a couple slices and it made excellent toast...I am so glad I bought this bread machine! It was the cheapest in price and it works GREAT! I bought it at Walmart.com and I had it in a couple of days!...Love it!

    YouTube comment · @ArtistVicki · 2014-12-14 · watch the original ↗

  • The Hamilton beach bread machine recipes in its manual always ALWAYS over rise and push the lid open and make a huge mess EVERY TIME!! I’ve tried using less yeast, more salt, less sugar, etc etc, different bread machine recipes from YouTube, no matter. It over rises ALWAYS.

    Reddit post · u/Willing-Research-375 · r/BreadMachines · 2025-03-06 · read the original ↗

  • I have recently returned to using my hamilton beach horizontal bread maker. It makes great basic bread . I usually use the 1 1/2 lb size which is just right for my husband and me. But the damn large paddle hole is driving me mad.

    Reddit post · u/Melsm1957 · r/BreadMachines · 2024-07-30 · read the original ↗

  • I just got the Hamilton Beach bread maker 2 days ago. Tried to make a first loaf, the paddle was apparently not working. Got that fixed and tested it to make sure, made a second attempt last night and it seems to have paused itself at some point and stopped in the middle of kneading. This morning it was just a hard lump of dough and it had reset itself back to the original amount of time.

    Reddit post · u/Cirrus646 · r/BreadMachines · 2026-03-24 · read the original ↗

  • However, i have it on my island and i currently need to put the 5lb bag of flour behind it and any other heavy item that's available in front of it in order to prevent it from throwing itself off the counter during the kneading process.

    Reddit post · u/Outrageous_Advice796 · r/BreadMachines · 2026-01-11 · read the original ↗

  • I just got the Hamilton Beach HomeBaker 2 lb. Breadmaker 29881 for $0.99 at Goodwill! Any other bread suggestions that aren’t in the manual?

    Reddit post · u/Fluteh · r/BreadMachines · 2024-10-19 · read the original ↗

  • this is a "home baker" because it does much more than bread I bought this bread machine because my old one broke - got to say over all this Hamilton Beach bread making mode of the machine gets a 10 out of 10

    YouTube review · jmarylastone · 2014-12-14 · watch the original ↗

Frequently asked questions

Does a bread machine actually save money over store-bought bread?

A little, but owners say the real payoff is better bread and knowing what went into it, not savings.

Why does my loaf have a big hole in the bottom, or come out lopsided?

The hole is the paddle baked into the loaf, which many owners pull out before the final rise, and lopsided loaves on two-paddle machines mean the paddles were not aligned.

Should I bake in the machine or just use it to knead the dough?

Plenty of experienced owners only run the dough cycle and bake in a regular oven for a better crust and a normal shape.

How long do bread machines last?

The premium machines routinely run fifteen to thirty years, budget ones vary widely, and the non-stick pan wears out before the motor on any brand.

How this ranking was made

Every quote on this page links to the post or video it came from, so you can read it in context. ✓ 56 quotes from 55 distinct voices.