vilagai

✓ 55 sourced quotes

Ranked by evidence

5 Best Cold Brew Coffee Makers of 2026, Ranked by Owner Reviews

Published

I've been using the Takeya for about 15 years and it works like a breeze. Had a Toddy before that but prefer the Takeya because it takes up less space. Love using it for iced tea, with loose tea leaves, too.— Reddit comment · u/margoembargo · r/Coffee · 2025-04-07 · on the #1 pick, Takeya Cold Brew Maker

  1. 1 Takeya Cold Brew MakerBest overall 12 sources
  2. 2 OXO Cold Brew MakerBest upgrade pick 13 sources
  3. 3 Toddy Cold Brew SystemMost proven 12 sources
  4. 4 County Line Kitchen Mason Jar MakerBest value 7 sources
  5. 5 Hario MizudashiMost compact 11 sources
1
Best overall

Takeya Cold Brew Maker

Patented Deluxe / Tritan plastic

Illustration of Takeya Cold Brew Maker Illustration of the product
Takeya Cold Brew Maker — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Best for
Simplicity, one container straight into the fridge
Material
BPA-free Tritan plastic
Concentrate or ready-to-drink
Concentrate

Why it ranks here. The one most people buy first: a pitcher with a mesh filter inside that goes straight into the fridge, dishwasher safe, and it doubles as an iced tea pitcher. One owner has used it for about fifteen years and prefers it to the Toddy she had before because it takes less space, and another calls it quality built after two years.

Several owners find the coffee a bit weak even with the chamber full, so pack the filter and go easy on dilution. It makes a lot of fine silt for some, who run the brew through a paper filter afterwards, and a couple of buyers got grounds floating loose despite following the instructions. It is plastic, which bothers owners who would rather steep overnight in glass.

What owners like

  • One pitcher, no carafe
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Fifteen years for one owner

What owners complain about

  • Comes out weak
  • Silt gets through
  • Plastic

I've been using the Takeya for about 15 years and it works like a breeze. Had a Toddy before that but prefer the Takeya because it takes up less space. Love using it for iced tea, with loose tea leaves, too.— Reddit comment · u/margoembargo · r/Coffee · 2025-04-07

3 positive · 2 mixed · 1 neutral · 6 negative · 11 voices · ✓ all 12 linked to source

Read all 12 quotes (11 voices)
  • I've been using the Takeya for about 15 years and it works like a breeze. Had a Toddy before that but prefer the Takeya because it takes up less space. Love using it for iced tea, with loose tea leaves, too.

    Reddit comment · u/margoembargo · r/Coffee · 2025-04-07 · read the original ↗

  • I've used it before and wasn't a fan. The coffee was a bit too weak even with the chamber fully filled.

    Reddit comment · u/rahulcopter · r/Coffee · 2020-06-11 · read the original ↗

  • That was my problem, I was never able to get it strong enough. Always had a watered down taste now matter the brand of beans

    Reddit comment · u/seasalt- · r/Coffee · 2020-06-11 · read the original ↗

  • Pros: * Super easy, all-in-one container that fits on any shelf in my fridge * Can use as a regular pitcher when needed * Cheap and still goin strong Cons: * Have to clean the mesh filter with soap and water since you can see it stained brown from the coffee, and it's a little tedious, it'd be nice to have a filter I could just toss instead * Gotta figure out how to eyeball the right amount of water so it doesn't cause an overflow when you stick the full filter in * Once your brewing is done and you take the filter/grinds out, you're left with about a 3/4 or 4/5 full container.

    Reddit comment · u/Ode1st · r/Coffee · 2020-06-12 · read the original ↗

  • Oh a huge negative for me that I forgot to mention: the Takeya makes a lot of silt. I have to filter it through a paper filter after it brews. It's annoying, for some reason brewed coffee just doesn't want to flow through a paper filter. Takes like 15-20 minutes for the jug.

    Reddit comment · u/Ode1st · r/Coffee · 2020-06-12 · read the original ↗

  • Just got one a week ago and love it

    Reddit comment · u/Giontatas · r/Coffee · 2020-06-11 · read the original ↗

  • This a great product and its quality built. I have been using mine for 2 years. We love it.

    YouTube comment · @GreyGhost-r4z · 2013-09-26 · watch the original ↗

  • This thing is horrible. I just bought it off Amazon and made my first pitcher today. I followed instructions to a T, im using coarse ground coffee, everything is completely screwed in perfect and tight but when I shake it up like I'm supposed too. There are coffee grounds floating everywhere in the pitcher!!

    YouTube comment · @BruhSayWhat · 2013-09-26 · watch the original ↗

  • Bad experience for me. Tried to make two brews so far, and each time it would end up with coffee grounds in the water. Ordered a replacement, I think mine was defective. Unless I'm doing things incorrectly.

    YouTube comment · @Wisefury · 2022-03-07 · watch the original ↗

  • For me glass free is negative. Prefer glass than plastic. Special if something i is soaking for hours before You drink. Glass has a high resistance to leeching into drink even when contained for long period of time.

    YouTube comment · @kamuda1982 · 2022-03-07 · watch the original ↗

  • Regarding the 7 cups "issue," If you place the filter (with coffee) into the brewer first (before the water), and soak the coffee with two cups of water, letting it soak for a few minutes, you can add 5-6 more cups after that.

    YouTube comment · @ronspi · 2022-03-07 · watch the original ↗

  • Takeya Cold Brew Coffee Maker REVIEW

    YouTube review · Games With Denver James · 2022-03-07 · watch the original ↗

2
Best upgrade pick

OXO Cold Brew Maker

Good Grips / Compact

Illustration of OXO Cold Brew Maker Illustration of the product
OXO Cold Brew Maker — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Best for
Stronger, cleaner concentrate if you have the counter space
Material
Plastic brew chamber + glass carafe
Concentrate or ready-to-drink
Strong concentrate

Why it ranks here. The answer when someone asks what to buy after the Takeya: it beat pricier rivals in a head-to-head test and has the most consistently happy long-term owners here, several at five to nine years. A convert from the Hario finds the cold brew ten times more flavourful and is never going back, the mesh plus optional paper filter gives a cleaner cup, the brewing chamber lifts off the carafe so the next batch starts right away, and OXO replaces broken parts free.

The base is bulky in the fridge, though you only need it for draining. The glass carafe broke on first use for one owner, who called it garbage. A fine grind can stretch the drain to hours, and OXO's own ratio makes a concentrate strong enough that first-timers misjudge it.

What owners like

  • Cleanest cup
  • Chamber lifts off for the next batch
  • Nine years and free parts

What owners complain about

  • Bulky base
  • Carafe broke for some
  • Slow with a fine grind

Just upgraded from the Hario to the Oxo- I'm never going back. The oxo is amaaaazing, the cold brew is 10 times more flavorful since the grounds are able fully incorporate with the water and steep properly. It's easier to clean (dishwasher), it makes a lot more cold brew for similarish bean ratios... first time I drank it I misjudged my serving by like 2 and a half and could basically smell colors.— Reddit comment · u/forestina · r/Coffee · 2017-09-06

9 positive · 3 mixed · 1 neutral · 13 voices · ✓ all 13 linked to source

Read all 13 quotes (13 voices)
  • oxo's cold brew maker is inexpensive, simple, and works very well. i love it

    Reddit comment · u/akajudge · r/Coffee · 2025-04-06 · read the original ↗

  • Thirding this. I've been using it for 5 years and I love it

    Reddit comment · u/AntBot27 · r/Coffee · 2025-04-07 · read the original ↗

  • My exact experience as well. Essentially the same method as the toddy without the expense of custom filters. Ours has been going for almost 9 years without major incident (other than the carafe breaking years ago, which was not a design issue.

    Reddit comment · u/VenusInFursona · r/Coffee · 2025-04-13 · read the original ↗

  • Just upgraded from the Hario to the Oxo- I'm never going back. The oxo is amaaaazing, the cold brew is 10 times more flavorful since the grounds are able fully incorporate with the water and steep properly. It's easier to clean (dishwasher), it makes a lot more cold brew for similarish bean ratios... first time I drank it I misjudged my serving by like 2 and a half and could basically smell colors.

    Reddit comment · u/forestina · r/Coffee · 2017-09-06 · read the original ↗

  • With my oxo, I've always tried to squeeze the most as I possibly can out of it. When I first got it I was slightly disappointed that I wasn't getting a full decanter of cold brew. After a good amount of experimentation, I have found that using a full 12 ounce bag of coffee with about 48 oz of water will yield a strong concentrate and fill almost the entire container full of concentrate.

    Reddit comment · u/Dr_Dabber_Drew · r/Coffee · 2017-10-17 · read the original ↗

  • I actually ended up ordering a 58.5 mm espresso puck screen which fits great and works fine as a replacement metal mesh filter. They're about $7-10 on Amazon.

    Reddit comment · u/CarlFriedrichGauss · r/Coffee · 2022-08-06 · read the original ↗

  • Same here, dropped mine down the disposal. Called and they replaced for free. Great customer service!

    Reddit comment · u/Dapper-Judge-2579 · r/Coffee · 2025-09-25 · read the original ↗

  • honestly i am consistently surprised at how well oxo makes kitchen stuff

    YouTube comment · @cyclopsboi · 2023-05-19 · watch the original ↗

  • I've been using the oxo for years and love it. Regarding the bulkiness, you don't need to use the base for mixing, brewing, or any part of the process except draining the finished concentrate... I bought mine years ago, so I don't know if the carafes have gotten any better, but mine was garbage. It broke on the first use while applying the top with what I thought was a very reasonable amount of pressure...

    YouTube comment · @adam_sorber · 2023-05-19 · watch the original ↗

  • I love the oxo and have been using it for years now. I find that adding about 25% of the water before any grounds and just use the built in metal filter gives me great texture and no fines.

    YouTube comment · @brendanwhalen3607 · 2023-05-19 · watch the original ↗

  • I have been using the OXO Cold Brew system for about 3 years now, and I have been putting a wet AeroPress paper filter on top of the mesh filter, inside the brewing chamber

    YouTube comment · @james.randorff · 2023-05-19 · watch the original ↗

  • This video conflicts with the other SCG in terms of ratio used. Here it's 6:1 and most other SGD videos recommend 4:1. Even if it's 6:1, that would be a concentrate level and not drunk straight like this guy does in this video.

    YouTube comment · @troym3219 · 2020-08-19 · watch the original ↗

  • Oxo Compact Cold Brewer | Crew Review

    YouTube review · Seattle Coffee Gear · 2020-08-19 · watch the original ↗

3
Most proven

Toddy Cold Brew System

Home Model

Illustration of Toddy Cold Brew System Illustration of the product
Toddy Cold Brew System — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Best for
Long-haul owners who want the benchmark taste
Material
Plastic brew bucket + glass carafe
Concentrate or ready-to-drink
Concentrate

Why it ranks here. The original, the benchmark taste every other maker gets compared to, with the longest-serving owners of any brand here: one from 1998 with every original part, another well past forty years, and a fifteen-year owner making weekly batches all summer because it is just so easy. Felt filters and stoppers are cheap, and Toddy's own support steps into owner threads with fixes and warranty help.

The plastic bucket tends to crack around the stopper hole after a few years and leak; one owner has bought two in five years. Toddy's advice is a gentle quarter-turn on the stopper and no dishwasher, and owners glue a stainless washer over the hole. Some feel they are paying a lot for a plastic bucket and a glass carafe.

What owners like

  • The benchmark taste
  • Owners at forty years
  • Cheap parts, helpful support

What owners complain about

  • Bucket cracks at the stopper
  • Pricey for what it is

I bought my Toddy somewhere between mid 1998 to mid 1999 and I haven't had a problem with it yet though I still put it in a pot to brew in case it leaks out. I almost always fill it up at night and drain it in the morning. I still have all of the original parts, brewer, plug, carafe, and lid.— Reddit comment · u/zaffiromite · r/Coffee · 2021-06-24

4 positive · 6 mixed · 1 neutral · 1 negative · 12 voices · ✓ all 12 linked to source

Read all 12 quotes (12 voices)
  • I live my Toddy. I bought when I was near the beginning of my coffee journey on the advice of a friend and have had it for 15 years with weekly batches all summer. It's just so easy to use... I live the taste and the ease of use

    Reddit comment · u/gidget1337 · r/Coffee · 2022-05-24 · read the original ↗

  • I bought my Toddy somewhere between mid 1998 to mid 1999 and I haven't had a problem with it yet though I still put it in a pot to brew in case it leaks out. I almost always fill it up at night and drain it in the morning. I still have all of the original parts, brewer, plug, carafe, and lid.

    Reddit comment · u/zaffiromite · r/Coffee · 2021-06-24 · read the original ↗

  • I'm bummed because I really like the Toddy, but for what it is, it ain't exactly cheap and I've already bought 2 of these fuckers over the last 4 - 5 years... it seems that the hole/stopper parts of the apparatus have failed as every time I came back to check on it, water was slowly but actively leaking out.

    Reddit post · u/Doza93 · r/Coffee · 2021-06-21 · read the original ↗

  • The brew containers may crack if the stopper is pushed in too hard too often. To remedy and keep the brew container from cracking in the future, we recommend gently pressing the stopper into place and turning it a quarter turn to seal... we do not recommend washing the brew container in the dishwasher as the high temperature environment... can cause the area around the stopper hole to become brittle and crack after time.

    Reddit comment · u/ToddyLLC · r/Coffee · 2021-07-06 · read the original ↗

  • I have experienced the dreaded hairline crack near the stopper hole in the bottom of the brew container on several containers. Because I love Toddy brew system I have always accepted the problem as inevitable and moved on. But no more! I simply adhered, with food grade adhesive available on Amazon and many other sites, a 1.5" diameter stainless steel washer, with a .5" hole, to the bottom of the Toddy brew container. This immediately stopped the leak

    Reddit comment · u/Many-Being2364 · r/Coffee · 2025-09-16 · read the original ↗

  • For future folks who find this thread: I had the same crack form in the bottom hole in my Toddy after 5+ years. I rubbed super glue into the crack and let it dry and now it plugs well! Should extend the life a while longer.

    Reddit comment · u/requestedRerun · r/Coffee · 2024-07-07 · read the original ↗

  • Unfortunate update.... It works. It's not the worst way I've filtered it before. But it's been draining for about 4 hours now. It's a SUPER slow draw-down, so if you have the time it works fine, but it is nowhere near as convenient as the original Toddy filter.

    Reddit comment · u/somethinggooddammit · r/Coffee · 2022-05-24 · read the original ↗

  • I've been using my Toddy for well over 40 years, and I run it through the dishwasher every time, so it's still white. Mine doesn't even have a handle, that's how old it is.

    YouTube comment · @Joannakathryn · 2019-10-21 · watch the original ↗

  • Bought my toddy back in 2015 and it's still going strong.

    YouTube comment · @mikerobinson883 · 2019-10-21 · watch the original ↗

  • I followed Option 2 instructions in the manual that came with my unit... The 'unfortunate' part was that I got significantly less finished product than you did in the video. I think I might have got about 60% the amount of coffee that you got in the video... Good news is that the end product tastes great

    YouTube comment · @truenorth2615 · 2019-10-21 · watch the original ↗

  • If he showed the toddy bucket and it was white, I would doubt he used it for 2 years. I just used the toddy that my gf got me and one use, that thing is toast. Clearly means this dude used and abused his toddy. I will trust his review

    YouTube comment · @Tomasuken · 2019-10-21 · watch the original ↗

  • Toddy Cold Brew Coffee [2-Year Review] & Tutorial

    YouTube review · Travis DeRose · 2019-10-21 · watch the original ↗

4
Best value

County Line Kitchen Mason Jar Maker

Mason jar style

Illustration of County Line Kitchen Mason Jar Maker Illustration of the product
County Line Kitchen Mason Jar Maker — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Best for
Budget buyers who want glass over plastic
Material
Glass jar with stainless mesh filter
Concentrate or ready-to-drink
Concentrate

Why it ranks here. The glass alternative for people who do not want to steep coffee overnight in plastic, at about the Takeya's price. One owner has had it almost five years of summer use, another loves it and keeps a second jar brewing so she never runs out, the thick jar works as a regular pitcher once the filter is out, and the gasket has been redesigned to seal both edges of the filter rim.

Pre-ground coffee is the argument: it clogs and adds grit for some owners and causes no issues for others, probably down to how fine each brand grinds, so buy coarse or grind your own. It has a much smaller owner base than the big brands, so long-term reports are thin.

What owners like

  • Thick glass, no plastic
  • Doubles as a pitcher
  • Five years for one owner

What owners complain about

  • Pre-ground can clog
  • Thin long-term record

I've had the County Line for almost five years and use it every summer. Great cold brew system.— YouTube comment · @Clayton_Bigsby · 2022-03-27

4 positive · 1 mixed · 1 neutral · 1 negative · 7 voices · ✓ all 7 linked to source

Read all 7 quotes (7 voices)
  • I've had the County Line for almost five years and use it every summer. Great cold brew system.

    YouTube comment · @Clayton_Bigsby · 2022-03-27 · watch the original ↗

  • I love this contraption. I prefer a finer grind, dark roast, steeped at room temp for 24hrs. Makes a nice concentrate which lasts me all week (in the bigger jar.) I keep a smaller jar with an extra pour cap. When I'm down far enough in the bigger jar, I transfer it to save room in the fridge and have another one brewing on deck so I never run out.

    YouTube comment · @jordancrowderfilms · 2022-03-27 · watch the original ↗

  • For ready to drink coffee (not concentrate) use 50g course ground coffee and 75 ml water for a 1 quart jar or 100g course ground coffee and 1500 ml water for a 2 quart jar. I recently bought just the County Line filter because I already had 2 quart jars and pouring lids. They've improved the silicone gasket. It now covers both the bottom and the top of the rim of the filter.

    YouTube comment · @nardamock · 2022-03-27 · watch the original ↗

  • Great tips! I've been using the pre-ground, and it has given me a lot of problems. I've also been trying to fill it up to the very top with grounds and water, and you've given me the idea of quitting that :D Thanks!

    YouTube comment · @unclvinny · 2019-05-10 · watch the original ↗

  • I use pre ground in that same setup and had 0 issues with grounds in the brew.

    YouTube comment · @Critical_minarchist · 2019-05-10 · watch the original ↗

  • I use ground coffee with no problems. I wonder if some ground coffees are ground finer than others...

    YouTube comment · @alanwhitsitt5196 · 2019-05-10 · watch the original ↗

  • How To Make Great Tasting Cold Brew / Iced Coffee In Mason Jar COUNTY LINE KITCHEN COFFEE MAKER

    YouTube review · Just A Dad Approved · 2022-03-27 · watch the original ↗

5
Most compact

Hario Mizudashi

Illustration of Hario Mizudashi Illustration of the product
Hario Mizudashi — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Best for
Ready-to-drink strength in small kitchens
Material
Glass carafe with plastic mesh basket
Concentrate or ready-to-drink
Ready-to-drink; cannot make a strong concentrate

Why it ranks here. The best-looking maker here, a glass carafe with a mesh basket hanging inside, and its fans use it daily for years: one for at least eight years, one who says it paid for itself in the first month, one who owns two. Cleanup is unscrew, dump and rinse.

The basket sits near the top and holds a fixed amount of coffee, barely touching the water, so it cannot make a real concentrate no matter what you do; owners who like strong cold brew find it watery and one suggests brewing in a jar and using the Hario as a strainer. Some find fine sediment gets through the mesh.

What owners like

  • Best looking
  • Easiest cleanup
  • Eight years of daily use

What owners complain about

  • Cannot make concentrate
  • Silt gets through

I got one as a gift about 3 years ago and it makes really nice cold brew. I find clean up to be pretty easy - remove filter, dump the bulk of the grinds, rinse the rest away. Only quibble is that it's not a good storage system after the brew - it's not air tight - if that matters.— Reddit comment · u/Gaudeamus_Igiturtle · r/Coffee · 2018-05-08

3 positive · 2 mixed · 1 neutral · 5 negative · 10 voices · ✓ all 11 linked to source

Read all 11 quotes (10 voices)
  • 100% this. The Hario Mizudashi is absolutely useless due to this exact problem... always came out weak and underextracted.

    Reddit comment · u/swroasting · r/Coffee · 2020-06-13 · read the original ↗

  • The Mizudashi uses an extra fine mesh filter, not metal. Because you'll be using a coarse grind, you'll get few (if any) fines. I use one almost daily, and I'm a big fan.

    Reddit comment · u/mill1484 · r/Coffee · 2018-05-08 · read the original ↗

  • i like mine so much that i have two!

    Reddit comment · u/danakaysucks · r/Coffee · 2018-05-09 · read the original ↗

  • I have the 1 L version and I don't like it. If you use just 60 grams of coffee, that fills up the filter completely and the coffee is barely touching the water. Normally I like to make cold brew about twice as strong. Cleaning the filter out completely can be a challenge too.

    Reddit comment · u/Wiz_Kalita · r/Coffee · 2018-05-08 · read the original ↗

  • Mizudashi can't make a concentrate. Do it in a mason jar with 1:4-6 ratio and use the Mizudashi as a strainer

    Reddit comment · u/kolormelar · r/Coffee · 2018-01-27 · read the original ↗

  • It's the device. The grounds container is at the top, so you can't reduce your water, and it's a fixed size, so you can't add more grounds. It's essentially a built-in fixed ratio, and it cannot make a cold brew strong enough for my tastes.

    Reddit comment · u/swroasting · r/Coffee · 2018-01-27 · read the original ↗

  • So I tried this pitcher a few years ago and found the same thing as you. I could never get it strong enough. On top of that, I found that the mesh let a lot of silt through into my coffee... For what it's worth, I do 12-1 ratio for 24 hours with great results [with a nut milk bag instead]

    Reddit comment · u/Bubs12 · r/Coffee · 2018-01-27 · read the original ↗

  • I got one as a gift about 3 years ago and it makes really nice cold brew. I find clean up to be pretty easy - remove filter, dump the bulk of the grinds, rinse the rest away. Only quibble is that it's not a good storage system after the brew - it's not air tight - if that matters.

    Reddit comment · u/Gaudeamus_Igiturtle · r/Coffee · 2018-05-08 · read the original ↗

  • I make and leave on counter overnight and it's very easy to hand wash. I've had at least 8 years. It paid for itself the first month.

    YouTube comment · @a.m.murphy6491 · 2019-10-22 · watch the original ↗

  • I bought one and was trying to figure the japanese instructions, i thought it wrote 8hrs so my coffee ended up being pretty bland. will do 24 hrs in future, thanks for the informative video!

    YouTube comment · @solidandsoiled · 2019-10-22 · watch the original ↗

  • EASIEST COLD BREW Coffee Maker for only $35! Hario Mizudashi Cold Brew Review

    YouTube review · Is It Worth It Luxury Reviews · 2020-04-27 · watch the original ↗

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between cold brew concentrate and ready-to-drink cold brew?

Most pitcher makers here produce a strong concentrate you cut with water or milk, while the hanging-basket type makes drinking strength and cannot be pushed further.

How long should cold brew steep, and in the fridge or on the counter?

Twelve to twenty-four hours, mostly in the fridge, with longer steeps stronger and less acidic until a fine grind turns it muddy.

Why is my cold brew maker draining so slowly or clogging?

Almost always a grind that is too fine for the filter, so use a coarse French-press grind and do not stir after adding water.

Do these makers leave grounds or sediment in the drink?

Some silt gets through on nearly every product, and a paper filter or a nut-milk bag afterwards is the fix owners use.

How this ranking was made

Every quote on this page links to the post or video it came from, so you can read it in context. ✓ 55 quotes from 53 distinct voices.