vilagai

✓ 66 sourced quotes

Ranked by evidence

Best budget climbing shoes

As for your post title, no it would not be stupid to get a version of the Tarantula. I'd wager it's the most popular first shoe globally. Can't think of anything that'd be smarter without specifics.— Reddit comment · u/Airewalt · r/climbingshoes · 2024-12-30 · on the #1 pick, La Sportiva Tarantulace

  1. 1 La Sportiva TarantulaceMost proven 20 quotes
  2. 2 Black Diamond MomentumBest for narrow-average feet 14 quotes
  3. 3 Evolv DefyBest overall 14 quotes
  4. 4 Butora EndeavorBest for wide feet 8 quotes
  5. 5 Climb X RaveBest value 10 quotes
1
Most proven

La Sportiva Tarantulace

Lace and Velcro versions available

Illustration of La Sportiva Tarantulace Illustration of the product
La Sportiva Tarantulace — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Fit
Flat, roomy last; stretches noticeably with wear
Best for
First-time buyers, gym beginners, anyone wanting a cheap backup pair for abrasive rock

Why it ranks here. By far the most talked-about budget shoe across Reddit (r/climbing, r/bouldering, r/climbingshoes) and YouTube gear channels — repeatedly called 'the most popular first shoe globally.' It's cheap (~$80-99), fits a wide range of feet, and is widely recommended as a no-brainer starter shoe, even though durability and rubber quality are frequent complaints.

Owners overwhelmingly say the Tarantulace is comfortable out of the box, flat/neutral enough to learn footwork in, and good value at roughly $80 (MSRP crept to $99 by 2025). The recurring complaint is durability: many climbers report toe rubber wearing through or the rand/sole delaminating within 2-6 months, especially with beginner footwork (toe-dragging). Several users note La Sportiva has had recurring glue-quality issues 'almost every year.' Despite that, people who wear through a pair often just buy another because they're so cheap, and many say the shoe took them to V4-V9 or 5.11 without holding them back. Sizing advice varies (some say true-to-street-size, others say downsize half a size); the shoe stretches noticeably over months of use.

What owners like

  • The default recommendation in nearly every 'first shoe' thread — one climber called it 'the most popular first shoe globally'
  • Flat, neutral shape that's genuinely useful for learning footwork, and owners report reaching V4-V9 or 5.11 in them
  • Cheap enough that replacing a worn pair doesn't sting: 'Yes definitely get a cheaper pair. These are around $80 and are some of the cheapest'

What owners complain about

  • Toe rubber and soles are prone to wearing through or delaminating early — 'the toes burn through really fucking quickly'
  • Reports of recurring glue-quality issues: 'La Sportiva has issues with their glue almost every year, it's hit and miss'
  • Durability is inconsistent pair to pair — some owners get 2+ years, others get 2 months before holes appear

As for your post title, no it would not be stupid to get a version of the Tarantula. I'd wager it's the most popular first shoe globally. Can't think of anything that'd be smarter without specifics.— Reddit comment · u/Airewalt · r/climbingshoes · 2024-12-30

9 positive · 4 mixed · 1 neutral · 6 negative · 19 voices · ✓ all 20 linked to source

Read all 20 quotes (19 voices)
  • Yea, it's definitely been a learning experience, I am getting better the more I climb. I've been about 50x in the past 3 months. I am currently thinking I am just going to wear these until they are unwareable and wait till REI has a sale to replace them

    Reddit comment · u/BillDino · r/climbing · 2018-06-11 · read the original ↗

  • Yes definitely get a cheaper pair. These are around $80 and are some of the cheapest

    Reddit comment · u/BillDino · r/climbing · 2018-06-12 · read the original ↗

  • The LS Tarantulace is a really cheap shoe. Replace and resole cost is comparable, so you mind as well just replace.

    Reddit comment · u/Pooopdolla · r/climbing · 2018-06-12 · read the original ↗

  • The toes burn through really fucking quickly. Otherwise, I liked them a lot.

    Reddit comment · u/Ferkhani · r/climbing · 2019-08-05 · read the original ↗

  • Hm, so far they worked great for me. And lots of my friends have them too, no issues with the rubber so far, we are climbing frankenjura in Germany mostly

    Reddit comment · u/gym_meier · r/climbing · 2019-08-05 · read the original ↗

  • Same. I owned tarantulace and used them for 6 months. The rubber is so terrible, imo. Got some muiras after and the difference is night and day.

    Reddit comment · u/Nnnnnbbbbb · r/climbing · 2019-08-05 · read the original ↗

  • Since this is probably considered ordinary wear and tear I don't have the option to return them to the store I purchased them at. I know shoes do wear out, but 80$ for a pair that wore out in 2 months, that's not "cheap" if you ask me.

    Reddit comment · u/provin1327 · r/climbing · 2016-01-05 · read the original ↗

  • I've seen at least 4 pairs of Tarantulaces and the velcro ones both get tears in the leather, soles delaminating, seams ripping, etc early on in their ownership. They're cheap Sportivas for a reason I guess.

    Reddit comment · u/thegroverest · r/climbing · 2016-01-05 · read the original ↗

  • La Sportiva has issues with their glue almost every year, it's hit and miss. My first pair of futuras lasted 3+ years of extensive use, but the rand at the 2nd pair I bought delaminated after 5 days or less outside.

    Reddit comment · u/t0asti · r/climbing · 2016-01-05 · read the original ↗

  • My tarantula inside edge peeled at the sole due to glue failure after a very short while, ans I see pics here of others having the same issue too. Definitely don't recommend the.

    Reddit comment · u/Kayrehn · r/bouldering · 2024-01-30 · read the original ↗

  • Tarantulace fits amazing? Get it. It's a solid shoe and a lot of people I know (myself included) started with that one. I've been climbing for 2 years now and gone up to V5 and the Tarantulace still fits my needs (and my feet).

    Reddit comment · u/81659354597538264962 · r/bouldering · 2024-01-14 · read the original ↗

  • Tarantulace was my go-to for my first 5-ish years of climbing and I see people at the gym sending V7 in them all the time, so they definitely won't hold you back from progressing. I still have a pair around for JTree trips because I can wear them for hours of dicking around on those super abrasive rocks and not screw up my more expensive shoes.

    Reddit comment · u/mr_renfro · r/bouldering · 2024-01-14 · read the original ↗

  • I personally liked the tarantulas since there's no lace and to be honest I climbed in them a bunch including a bunch of v9s

    Reddit comment · u/moonkeyedd · r/bouldering · 2024-01-14 · read the original ↗

  • Tarantulas were my first shoe. Those bad boys got me my first V4. Absolute horse shit shoes for tiny painful foot chips on slab, but as a beginner, that prpb won't be an issue until you're ready to replace em anyway.

    Reddit comment · u/odd_leo · r/bouldering · 2024-01-14 · read the original ↗

  • I got the tarantulas for my first shoe and they've lasted me ages! I've only recently replaced them after about 12 months. Very comfortable and capable shoe that's a huge step up from rentals. In the UK they are also some of the cheapest available (about £70) unless you go to decathlon or something.

    Reddit comment · u/Electrical_Mix_7167 · r/climbingshoes · 2024-12-30 · read the original ↗

  • As for your post title, no it would not be stupid to get a version of the Tarantula. I'd wager it's the most popular first shoe globally. Can't think of anything that'd be smarter without specifics.

    Reddit comment · u/Airewalt · r/climbingshoes · 2024-12-30 · read the original ↗

  • Tarantulace is a great place to start. They're cheap and decent. Expensive shoes won't help much as a beginner anyway. You'll probably get your size wrong the first time and the laces are more forgiving in finding a right fit. These will stretch for a few months but once broke in they are very comfortable. Sometimes I wished they had a sharper edge but it never really mattered until 5.11s and still mostly doesn't.

    Reddit comment · u/throwaway1736484 · r/climbingshoes · 2024-12-31 · read the original ↗

  • My La Sportiva Tarantulas lasted me years and wore in like house slippers.

    YouTube comment · @sirg-had8821 · 2025 · watch the original ↗

  • This video rounds up on all beginner topics. Thanks! ... FYI, its been 5 years and it still costs $80.

    YouTube comment · @saurabhnba · 2019 · watch the original ↗

  • I've been climbing in my Tarantulace's for over 2 years now. I love the fit. But I just got holes through the toes, all the way through. I just bought La Sportiva Solution and my first route made me want my Taratulace's back....

    YouTube comment · @Stranger_Strange_Land · 2022 · watch the original ↗

2
Best for narrow-average feet

Black Diamond Momentum

Velcro, lace, and vegan versions; older knit-toebox vs newer cloth-toebox models differ

Illustration of Black Diamond Momentum Illustration of the product
Black Diamond Momentum — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Fit
Narrow, Roman-style toe box; not ideal for wide feet
Best for
Gym climbers with average-to-narrow feet who want a comfy warm-up shoe

Why it ranks here. Black Diamond's entry-level shoe is a constant recommendation alongside the Tarantulace and shows up in nearly every 'first climbing shoe' thread. It's praised for comfort and a roomy, forgiving fit, but opinions are more polarized than the Tarantulace — a vocal contingent calls it 'the worst quality shoe' they've owned, and odor complaints are very common.

Fans like the Momentum's out-of-the-box comfort, flat/neutral last, and price (often found 20-30% off, current MSRP ~$100-120). Several climbers say it got them to V5-V6/5.11-5.12 as a gym shoe. Frequent complaints: it runs narrow for wide feet, has essentially no rubber on top of the toe (bad for toe hooks/overhangs), and multiple users report it stinks badly within weeks despite regular cleaning. A subset of climbers is quite negative on overall build quality and comfort, especially with the newer cloth-toebox version, which one reviewer said cut his toes until broken in. Sizing advice is inconsistent — some say true-to-street-size, one video explicitly warns not to downsize multiple sizes.

What owners like

  • Comfortable, roomy toe box for the right foot shape — one owner said it got him to his 'first V6'
  • Frequently found 20-30% off retail
  • Regularly reported taking gym climbers to 5.11-5.12 as a dedicated gym shoe

What owners complain about

  • Runs narrow and can cause real pain for wide feet: 'The shoes gave me chronic pain in the joint of my big toe'
  • Almost no rubber over the top of the toe, making toe hooks and overhangs a weak point
  • Notorious for smelling bad fast, even with regular cleaning: 'I wipe them out after every use too' and they still stink

I have these shoes and used them for months--- they're terrible if you have anything but narrow feet. You can get em' a size up from your street size, and they'll still be too narrow... The shoes gave me chronic pain in the joint of my big toe of my left foot, but at least it taught me how to treat my feet better.— Reddit comment · u/TedTran2019 · r/climbing · 2023-04-06

3 positive · 5 mixed · 1 neutral · 5 negative · 14 voices · ✓ all 14 linked to source

Read all 14 quotes (14 voices)
  • I am not a beginner, and I still use BD momentums as my gym bouldering shoe. They're cheap, comfortable, and work well enough on most terrain. I'm regularly able to find them for 20-30% off, which helps . Toe hooks, technical heel hooking, and horizontal roofs are definite weak spots, but those don't show up in a lot of beginner problems.

    Reddit comment · u/kiloyrinim · r/climbing · 2021-05-29 · read the original ↗

  • I have these shoes and used them for months--- they're terrible if you have anything but narrow feet. You can get em' a size up from your street size, and they'll still be too narrow... The shoes gave me chronic pain in the joint of my big toe of my left foot, but at least it taught me how to treat my feet better.

    Reddit comment · u/TedTran2019 · r/climbing · 2023-04-06 · read the original ↗

  • Great first buy. But i thought they would last a bit longer before the holes on big toe appeared. Either way i compared it to my friends first shoes and we're a bit more comfy on foot and i love material

    Reddit comment · u/Quririn · r/climbing · 2021-05-28 · read the original ↗

  • Try them on and pick the most comfortable one. BD Momentum are super comfy for a Roman toe box and I did my first V6 in them. That said, they have no rubber on top of the toes, so they are useless for overhangs requiring toe catches.

    Reddit comment · u/cowfishduckbear · r/bouldering · 2023-08-25 · read the original ↗

  • I found the finale a little too uncomfortable and the momentum a bit narrow. I went with the tarantula's in a size9.5 which were a little short for the first 2 sessions...

    Reddit comment · u/lonie1992 · r/bouldering · 2023-08-24 · read the original ↗

  • Defy. Momentums were my first shoe and they're just bad. Black Diamond does a lot of things right but shoes aren't one of them. Evolv shoes are pretty damn great, haven't met one I don't like yet, and the defy has been updated.

    Reddit comment · u/shutupingrate · r/climbingshoes · 2025-12-08 · read the original ↗

  • dont go with the bd shoes. i had this pair as a beginner pair and the quality of the shoe is the worst one i have ever came across.

    Reddit comment · u/slbando · r/climbingshoes · 2025-12-08 · read the original ↗

  • I've got a pair of the Momentums and have been very happy with them. Thought I had found a limitation of these shoes a couple weeks ago trying a bat hang start that I couldn't figure out.. was blaming the lack of rubber on top of the toe, but then figured it out and it wasn't the shoe at all...! I'm new ish to climbing and a V5 ish climber depending on the set.

    Reddit comment · u/Moose_R_HuGe · r/climbingshoes · 2025-12-08 · read the original ↗

  • Those Momentums are beginner level shoes. I wouldnt wear them for more advanced techniques, but they're fine for easy stuff and warmups.

    Reddit comment · u/357-Magnum-CCW · r/climbingshoes · 2025-12-08 · read the original ↗

  • I started climbing as soon as the two week shutdown ended as a way to get out of the house. I bought these shoes because they were the cheapest thing at REI. I could not be more happy with these shoes as they have taken me all the way to v6 and 5.12 .

    YouTube comment · @topfraggergaming4097 · 2020 · watch the original ↗

  • Momentum is my goto gym shoe. I've gotten up to 5.11 in it, and I think if I get another pair down 1/2 size, I may be able to get to 5.12

    YouTube comment · @RossPotts · 2020 · watch the original ↗

  • I've been wearing these for 3 months and they absolutely stink. I climb every 2 days and they absolutely stink after every climb and still stink 2 days later. I wipe them out after every use too.

    YouTube comment · @SeenThroughHaggis · 2020 · watch the original ↗

  • For anyone considering buying these, do NOT downsize. Especially not multiple sizes. I downsized by half a size and they are already extremely tight. hopefully they feel better after they're broken in.

    YouTube comment · @Ranger3486 · 2026 · watch the original ↗

  • There are two versions of Black Diamond Momentum: the one you had with a knit toebox, and the one with full cloth toebox... it is actually the opposite of everything you've mentioned as advantages... It is quite uncomfortable for a beginner shoe, because the cloth is quite stiff (my toes actually bled a lot till I broke them in), it does not breath at all... They are now discounted in our region to about 70 euroes, and it makes a bit more sense.

    YouTube comment · @MrStillfree69 · 2024 · watch the original ↗

3
Best overall

Evolv Defy

Lace and Velcro versions

Illustration of Evolv Defy Illustration of the product
Evolv Defy — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Fit
True-to-street-size to half a size up; some need a full size up
Best for
Climbers who want a beginner shoe that can also handle real mileage outdoors

Why it ranks here. The Defy has a long track record (over a decade of production) and is the single most-cross-referenced budget shoe in r/climbingshoes 'which shoe should I buy' threads, frequently beating both the Tarantulace and BD Momentum head-to-head. Multiple long-time owners call it exceptionally durable for the price (~$85-119).

Reviewers consistently praise the Defy's soft, sensitive rubber and durability — several say a single pair lasted 2+ years or multiple summers of regular use, and one commenter knows someone climbing V10 in them as a beater shoe. The one complaint that appears in every year of reviews is the smell: 'Don't get me started on the stank of these'. Sizing is reported as generally true-to-street-size to half-a-size-up for comfort, with a few people needing a full size up. A minority of reviewers found the rubber unremarkable or not sticky enough on small holds. It's frequently recommended over the Black Diamond Momentum in direct comparisons for material quality and performance.

What owners like

  • Consistently praised for soft, sensitive, sticky rubber that outperforms its price point
  • Exceptional durability track record — one owner: 'crazy durable, I've climbed a pair for like 2 summers now'
  • Over ten years of reviews say the same things, which is rarer than it sounds

What owners complain about

  • Near-universal odor complaints going back over ten years: 'Don't get me started on the stank of these...oh my lanta'
  • A minority of climbers find the rubber unremarkable on small holds compared to pricier shoes
  • Velcro version fits looser at the top than the lace version, according to owners

Evolv has a long track record with making the Defys good-value shoes that are more sensitive, stickier, and better-performing than a lot of other beginner shoes. And they've been making improvements to them over the years. I know a guy how who climbs V10s in them because he doesn't want to wear down his more expensive shoes.— Reddit comment · u/Newtothisredditbiz · r/climbingshoes · 2025-12-08

9 positive · 4 mixed · 1 negative · 14 voices · ✓ all 14 linked to source

Read all 14 quotes (14 voices)
  • They are so good for long multipitch climbs. I love my defys. They stink like crazy though.

    Reddit comment · u/doomglobe · r/climbing · 2013-05-14 · read the original ↗

  • Same here, even though I'm barely an Intermediate climber, I love my shoes.

    Reddit comment · u/casey_graz · r/climbing · 2013-05-14 · read the original ↗

  • I just burnt out a pair of Defy's that I bought last fall. They are extremely soft and actually pretty good to climb on. However, mine fell apart rather quickly... Don't get me started on the stank of these...oh my lanta. The smell coming from these things when I am wearing them 5+ hours a day outside is horrendous.

    Reddit comment · u/elitepetes · r/climbing · 2013-05-14 · read the original ↗

  • probably the most common beginner shoe i see ... for 85$ its not a bad shoe at all

    Reddit comment · u/bearbreeder · r/climbing · 2013-05-14 · read the original ↗

  • For that price point I would prefer Mad Rock flash. Evolv rubber is terrible, their workmanship is questionable, and they develop that epic stank. Every pair of shoes I have used from Evolv, I have found a better alternative somewhere else.

    Reddit comment · u/amrcnpsycho · r/climbing · 2013-05-15 · read the original ↗

  • Go defy!

    Reddit comment · u/Tillerrp · r/climbingshoes · 2025-12-08 · read the original ↗

  • Those defys are crazy durable, I've climbed a pair for like 2 summers now.

    Reddit comment · u/Unhappy-Figure3403 · r/climbingshoes · 2025-12-08 · read the original ↗

  • Evolv has a long track record with making the Defys good-value shoes that are more sensitive, stickier, and better-performing than a lot of other beginner shoes. And they've been making improvements to them over the years. I know a guy how who climbs V10s in them because he doesn't want to wear down his more expensive shoes.

    Reddit comment · u/Newtothisredditbiz · r/climbingshoes · 2025-12-08 · read the original ↗

  • The defy was my first shoe. Get the lace version. The upper Velcro doesn't make the top of the shoe fit very snug. Otherwise, great shoe for beginners

    Reddit comment · u/ccd3j · r/climbingshoes · 2025-12-08 · read the original ↗

  • Definitely the defy. The materials and construction are way better.

    Reddit comment · u/6spooky9you · r/climbingshoes · 2025-12-08 · read the original ↗

  • I have a pair velcro vision. I honestly think this is the best beginner/intermediate climbing shoes out there now. Go with street shoes or half size up should be fine.

    Reddit comment · u/Colorfulgreyy · r/climbingshoes · 2025-08-19 · read the original ↗

  • i just bought a pair (1st pair of climbing shoes) a couple weeks back & i've been climbing maybe 3 months. mine were the velcro ones but i ended up having to go 1.5 sizes up. initially ordered a single size but they were absolutely crushing my feet. 1.5 is still pretty snug but bearable.

    Reddit comment · u/Senior-Art6141 · r/climbingshoes · 2025-08-21 · read the original ↗

  • Just wanted to throw that out there for anyone looking for a great beginnermediate shoe at an excellent price.

    Reddit post · u/jfrosty42 · r/climbingshoes · 2025-10-05 · read the original ↗

  • These shoes helped me all the way up to V2, but I noticed I struggle a bit with them at V3. I feel like it's time for an upgrade

    YouTube comment · @zunbun9484 · 2023 · watch the original ↗

4
Best for wide feet

Butora Endeavor

Redesigned as 'Endeavor 2.0' in 2023; narrow and wide-fit versions

Illustration of Butora Endeavor Illustration of the product
Butora Endeavor — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Fit
Soft, forgiving, roomier toe box; good for wide feet
Best for
Beginners on slab/smearing terrain and wide-footed climbers who don't fit Scarpa/La Sportiva lasts

Why it ranks here. The Endeavor is Butora's flagship budget/beginner shoe (~$89-99, redesigned in 2023 as 'Endeavor 2.0') and is a common suggestion in r/climbingshoes and r/bouldering threads, praised for a roomier, softer fit than the Tarantulace/Momentum. It has fewer total reviews online than the top three shoes but a loyal, vocal fanbase.

Owners describe the Endeavor as comfy, flexy, and forgiving — good for slab and smearing — but not a shoe that excels at precision edging. Several long-term owners (2+ years) say they resoled and kept using theirs because they liked them so much. It's often compared favorably to the Mad Rock Rover as a wide-toe-box option for people who don't fit narrower Scarpa/La Sportiva lasts. One recurring negative theme unrelated to the shoe itself: a controversy around a former co-founder of Butora's US distributor led at least one commenter to say 'avoid Butoras,' though another commenter pushed back saying that person hasn't been affiliated with the company since 2019.

What owners like

  • Softer, roomier fit than the Tarantulace or Momentum — a good option for climbers who don't fit narrower lasts
  • Loyal long-term owners who resoled instead of replacing: 'I have since resoled the pair because I am happy with them'
  • Comfortable enough that owners describe two full years of regular use before needing anything done to them

What owners complain about

  • Not built for precision edging — 'okay beginner shoe, fine for slab and smearing but not great for anything requiring precision'
  • Smaller review footprint online than the other four shoes, making it harder to judge consistency
  • A vocal minority raises an ethical concern about a former co-founder of Butora's US distributor, separate from shoe quality

The endeavors are quite a bit less aggressive with a more generous toe box. The general feeling of the rover inside is a bit softer. I own both... I climbed 2 years in endeavor and love the shoes. I think endeavor is a more comfortable starting shoe.— Reddit comment · u/Marketfreshe · r/bouldering · 2024-06-15

4 positive · 1 mixed · 2 neutral · 1 negative · 8 voices · ✓ all 8 linked to source

Read all 8 quotes (8 voices)
  • They're an okay beginner shoe, fine for slab and smearing but not great for anything requiring precision. That said, they're super comfy and flexy. If you're relatively new to climbing they're fine for a beginner shoe to thrash until you're ready for something else.

    Reddit comment · u/MladenL · r/bouldering · 2024-07-23 · read the original ↗

  • The vibe seems to be that Butoras are the new So Ills

    Reddit comment · u/iode · r/bouldering · 2024-07-23 · read the original ↗

  • Avoid Butoras. Company is part owned by a sexual predator named Brad Hilbert.

    Reddit comment · u/Large_Cranberry_5142 · r/bouldering · 2024-07-23 · read the original ↗

  • I bought Butora Endeavor as my second climbing shoe. I wear EU 41 regular shoes and for Endeavor I bought size 40. Its a tight fit, but shoe fits my footshape perfectly, so its also comfortable... I have since resoled the pair because I am happy with them.

    Reddit comment · u/u86738632 · r/bouldering · 2024-06-15 · read the original ↗

  • The endeavors are quite a bit less aggressive with a more generous toe box. The general feeling of the rover inside is a bit softer. I own both... I climbed 2 years in endeavor and love the shoes. I think endeavor is a more comfortable starting shoe.

    Reddit comment · u/Marketfreshe · r/bouldering · 2024-06-15 · read the original ↗

  • I know somebody that bought them as a second pair of shoes after the LS Tarantula and he prefers the Climb X Rave shoes... If your footwork is not that great and they fit like a glove, I would go for the Climb X shoes.

    Reddit comment · u/_blooper · r/climbingshoes · 2025-08-18 · read the original ↗

  • Just bought a pair of the redwood Endeavors and I can't complain solid shoes 🤝💯

    YouTube comment · @ImJayTeezy · 2023 · watch the original ↗

  • Mac! You did it! I'm the guy that's written to Butora a couple of times about updating the Endeavor - this looks about exactly as I'd hoped. Great work and let me know if you need a pre-release tester.

    YouTube comment · @thesii213 · 2023 · watch the original ↗

5
Best value

Climb X Rave

Velcro closure, Amazon-primary listing

Illustration of Climb X Rave Illustration of the product
Climb X Rave — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Fit
Tight/narrow out of the box, stiff until broken in
Best for
Budget-conscious beginners and anyone wanting a cheap warm-up/beater shoe

Why it ranks here. The Rave is the standout 'Amazon-only' budget option, explicitly reviewed as 'Can You Get Good Climbing Shoes On Amazon?' It has the smallest footprint of the five in broader climbing forums (Climb X as a brand has a mixed older reputation), but the Rave specifically has generated a genuinely enthusiastic pocket of reviews on YouTube and in newer r/climbingshoes threads, largely because of its price (~$55-70).

Several fans call it 'basically a Tarantulace for half the cost,' with surprisingly sticky rubber, and multiple owners kept using theirs as a warm-up/beater shoe a year or more after buying. The price is volatile on Amazon (seen anywhere from $55 to $75), which annoys buyers who catch it at a spike. Complaints include a tight/narrow fit out of the box, visible glue on seams, stiffness before breaking in, weak slab performance according to at least one user, and rubber that one owner said wore out after a year of aggressive (4-6 hrs/week) use. Older Climb X products (cams, other shoe models, hardware) have a rockier reputation on r/climbing, including an infamous counterfeit-carabiner controversy, which is worth knowing even though it isn't about the Rave shoe itself.

What owners like

  • The cheapest shoe in the category by far, often $55-70, with reviewers surprised by the quality: 'I was pretty satisfied with the shoe... quite affordable for an entry level shoe'
  • Rubber described as 'surprisingly sticky' for the price, with fans running them as long-term warm-up shoes
  • Popular enough as gym rental stock in some regions to prove out its durability at scale: 'gyms always have them as rentals because they are that great'

What owners complain about

  • Price fluctuates noticeably on Amazon, sometimes jumping from $55 to $75 without warning
  • Runs tight and stiff out of the box, with visible glue on some seams
  • Weaker on slab according to at least one reviewer, and rubber wore out within a year under heavy use (4-6 hrs/week)

I got some on a whim after using Tarantulace for a while and was amazed by the quality relative to the price. They're basically Tarantulace for like half the cost.— YouTube comment · @evey0259 · 2025-04-12

5 positive · 3 mixed · 2 negative · 10 voices · ✓ all 10 linked to source

Read all 10 quotes (10 voices)
  • I dont believe I had anything to do with it, but the Climb X Rave shoes are now $69 on Amazon after being $55 for a long time. I still think they are great for $69...

    YouTube comment · @suckatslab · 2025-04-12 · watch the original ↗

  • The Raves were my first climbing shoe when I started back in Dec 2022. They are still my warm-up shoes today! A bit loose and comfy now but perfect for everything except hard projects. The rubber is surprisingly sticky. I do wear them with socks 😆

    YouTube comment · @jesenteh9022 · 2025-04-12 · watch the original ↗

  • I got some on a whim after using Tarantulace for a while and was amazed by the quality relative to the price. They're basically Tarantulace for like half the cost.

    YouTube comment · @evey0259 · 2025-04-12 · watch the original ↗

  • ClimbX is a very popular brand here in Malaysia lol, gyms always have them as rentals because they are that great but some gyms might not have them

    YouTube comment · @ZeqlLav · 2025-04-12 · watch the original ↗

  • These are $69.99 today😭 I bought a pair that was too small for the $55 bucks last week and now they're 75 with tax😔.. seems the price fluctuates

    YouTube comment · @Abe_Sinclair · 2025-04-12 · watch the original ↗

  • The climb x shoes are not good at slab

    YouTube comment · @HoganLiffe · 2025-04-12 · watch the original ↗

  • got these as my first shoes and they are awesome!

    YouTube comment · @chris_kdm · 2026-03-07 · watch the original ↗

  • I own a pair of Rave Climb X shoes (gray). Not bad but can be a little tight. Due to climbing aggressively 4-6hrs per week, the rubber wore out after 1 year.

    YouTube comment · @Joekool88 · 2018-04-30 · watch the original ↗

  • For this price point, I was pretty satisfied with the shoe. It fits nicely and I like the color and design. Solid flat sole that is good for beginners, and quite affordable for an entry level shoe... pros: -fits true to size, snug -quality material on upper -good design and color -easy on & off Velcro -affordable compared to majority of climbing shoes. cons: -visible glue on some seems -pretty stiff out of the box

    YouTube review · Simonderst13 (video description) · 2023-05-16 · watch the original ↗

  • I didn't know any better. Paid about 70 bucks for them, at the time I thought that was fine (even though you can get la sportiva tarantulaces for 80.) Not worth fixing or resoling when they become useless, I guess it works for a first pair.

    Reddit comment · u/Wafflesarepancakesv2 · r/climbing · 2018-03-17 · read the original ↗

Frequently asked questions

What size should I buy?

Beginners are told not to downsize. Momentum owners regret going half a size down, and Defy buyers often go up half a size or more. Laces forgive a slightly wrong size better than velcro.

How long do cheap climbing shoes last?

Anywhere from two months to two years. The Tarantulace wears through at the toe fastest, and the Evolv Defy has the best durability stories. Replacing an $80 pair costs about the same as a resole.

Will a beginner shoe hold me back?

No. Owners climb V7 and 5.12 in the Tarantulace and the Momentum. Footwork matters more than the shoe until you are standing on tiny footholds.

How this ranking was made

Every quote on this page links to the post or video it came from, so you can read it in context. ✓ 66 quotes from 65 distinct voices.