vilagai

✓ 38 sourced quotes

Ranked by evidence

4 Best Slow Cookers of 2026, Ranked by Owner Reviews

Published

My daughter got me one of these for christmas. At first I was thinking why do I need another croc pot that takes up so much space. Then I saw the proof feature......this has changed my whole bread making process. mix your dough, proof for 30 minutes, punch down, proof another 30 minutes, then bake for 30 and you have amazing bread in 2 hours. For me it was worth it just for the proof feature.— YouTube comment · ramboton · 2024-02 · on the #1 pick, Ninja Foodi PossibleCooker PRO

  1. 1 Ninja Foodi PossibleCooker PROBest overall 13 sources
  2. 2 Crock-Pot Cook & CarryBest for potlucks 9 sources
  3. 3 Hamilton Beach Set 'n ForgetBest value with a probe 9 sources
  4. 4 Crock-Pot 7-Qt ManualMost proven long-term 7 sources
1
Best overall

Ninja Foodi PossibleCooker PRO

8.5-Quart, model MC1001

Illustration of Ninja Foodi PossibleCooker PRO Illustration of the product
Ninja Foodi PossibleCooker PRO — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Capacity
8.5 qt
Controls
Digital, 8-in-1

Why it ranks here. The pot that made people give up on the regular crockpot: it sears and sautés in the same pot before slow cooking, proofs bread dough, bakes, holds a sous vide temperature, and goes from stovetop to oven. One owner's whole bread-making process changed with the proof setting, another made the best roast of her life without heating the kitchen, and one sent back every other Amazon slow cooker, Crock-Pot included, and kept this.

Low runs hotter than a classic crockpot; one owner measured Low at 130 degrees and High at 300, so cook times need adjusting. The sear function is not quite hot enough for a deep crust. A few owners saw the non-stick shed flecks, and Ninja says the lining is PTFE-free nano-ceramic. There is no true delay-start timer.

What owners like

  • Sears, proofs and sous vides in one pot
  • Best roasts owners have made
  • Nothing extra to scrub

What owners complain about

  • Low runs hot
  • Sear not hot enough
  • Non-stick flecks for a few

My daughter got me one of these for christmas. At first I was thinking why do I need another croc pot that takes up so much space. Then I saw the proof feature......this has changed my whole bread making process. mix your dough, proof for 30 minutes, punch down, proof another 30 minutes, then bake for 30 and you have amazing bread in 2 hours. For me it was worth it just for the proof feature.— YouTube comment · ramboton · 2024-02

8 positive · 2 mixed · 2 neutral · 1 negative · 13 voices · ✓ all 13 linked to source

Read all 13 quotes (13 voices)
  • My daughter got me one of these for christmas. At first I was thinking why do I need another croc pot that takes up so much space. Then I saw the proof feature......this has changed my whole bread making process. mix your dough, proof for 30 minutes, punch down, proof another 30 minutes, then bake for 30 and you have amazing bread in 2 hours. For me it was worth it just for the proof feature.

    YouTube comment · ramboton · 2024-02 · watch the original ↗

  • I had the same experience with Amazon slow cookers. I sent them all back. Even Crockpot brand wasn’t great. This is my new one.

    YouTube comment · tristayhat7088 · 2024-02 · watch the original ↗

  • I'm so glad you mentioned the low being very LOW. My experience is that the HIGH boils food over, and the Low does not even bring food to a whirlpool simmer bubble; the warm is seriously low. I tested my Low and it was 130 degrees, I tested High and its 300

    YouTube comment · awesomeastrid · 2024-02 · watch the original ↗

  • Had the same issue. My huge old standby favorite kitchenaid crockpot finally gave up the ghost and I tried several crocks and none of them measured up. My hubby felt sorry for me and surprised me with this beast. I’m loving it. Best kitchen addition I’ve had a in a long time. I agree about the sear temperature too. It’s not quite high enough but gets the job done.

    YouTube comment · Chasingthesun2019 · 2024-02 · watch the original ↗

  • Just got it on sale at sams club for $80 today, cannot wait to play with it! Thanks for the in depth advice

    YouTube comment · s0m3b0dysh3r0 · 2024-02 · watch the original ↗

  • This is what a review should be like. Down-to-earth, straightforward, honest, not glitzy, but technically well presented. The ordinary home chef will relate well to this. As for the Ninja, it survived the various tests well. We have several Ninja products, and this one will not be an exception.

    YouTube comment · davidwebber8578 · 2022-10 · watch the original ↗

  • Just got this at Costco for $80 So far I've only made chili, but it was great, brown the meat, and sear the veggies and then set it to slow cook. Made a nice large quantity. Loved it. It's going to be perfect for searing a roast before slow cooking

    YouTube comment · ENTITEA · 2022-10 · watch the original ↗

  • I made a pot roast with potatoes and carrots in mine yesterday. Was absolutely hands down the best roast I have ever made! It was falling apart! What I truly loved was the Ninja pot did not heat up my kitchen as it cooked all day long!

    YouTube comment · carolynbernal5511 · 2022-10 · watch the original ↗

  • I did purchase this item and ended up returning it. The non-stick was something different and every time I wiped the inside with paper towel, it would leave tiny pieces throughout the pan. Never ever had a single dish, pot, or pan do that.

    YouTube comment · mzztwink · 2022-10 · watch the original ↗

  • Finally heard back from the company, Shark/Ninja. The pot is lined with nano-ceramic. Here's the response copied/pasted: The inner pot of the Ninja Foodi PossibleCooker PRO is coated with nano-ceramic and is free from PTFE and PFOA, ensuring a safer and more durable cooking surface.

    YouTube comment · SandysDIYHealthAdvocacy · 2025-04 · watch the original ↗

  • I’m glad I read the comments about the coating, it was kind of a downer for me. Now not so much. I just did turkey soup in it and it did what I needed it to do... So all in all I just wanted something that I can use to set and forget.

    YouTube comment · annettehachey7909 · 2025-04 · watch the original ↗

  • The newest Pro Plus is $79.86 at Wal-Mart. I picked one up even though I may never use it. When My crock pot dies I will pull this out.

    YouTube comment · pohalsted8847 · 2025-04 · watch the original ↗

  • would love to know what you think of the Ninja Foodi Possible Cooker 8 in 1, as a slow cooker

    YouTube comment · geoffhorlock4566 · 2023-08 · watch the original ↗

2
Best for potlucks

Crock-Pot Cook & Carry

6-Quart, programmable

Illustration of Crock-Pot Cook & Carry Illustration of the product
Crock-Pot Cook & Carry — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Capacity
6 qt
Controls
Digital programmable with locking travel lid

Why it ranks here. The Crock-Pot most people picture, with a lid that locks shut for the drive to a potluck, and owners say it works. It is programmable from thirty minutes to twenty hours and switches itself to Warm when time is up, so working owners come home to no more overcooked meals, and six quarts feeds six to eight.

Long-term owners of every brand warn that the digital panel is the first thing to fail and that manual models are nearly immortal. The lid locks only for transport, not while cooking, which confuses first-time buyers. Like most modern slow cookers it runs hot, so old recipe times are too long, and one owner of the smaller size finds it too small and weak.

What owners like

  • Locking lid for transport
  • Programmable, auto-warm
  • Feeds six to eight

What owners complain about

  • Digital panel fails first
  • Lid locks only for transport
  • Runs hot

I absolutely LOVE this crock pot. It is programmable for high, low, and warm. It also has a timer so it comes in very handy when you are cooking on a time schedule... In the morning before I leave for work I simply set the crock pot on low or high for 6-8 hours (depending on the recipe) and when the timer is finished, it automatically switches it to "warm" when it's finished. No more overcooking meals!!— YouTube review · Amazon Kitchen Review (quoting a customer review) · 2018-08

1 positive · 3 mixed · 1 neutral · 4 negative · 9 voices · ✓ all 9 linked to source

Read all 9 quotes (9 voices)
  • I absolutely LOVE this crock pot. It is programmable for high, low, and warm. It also has a timer so it comes in very handy when you are cooking on a time schedule... In the morning before I leave for work I simply set the crock pot on low or high for 6-8 hours (depending on the recipe) and when the timer is finished, it automatically switches it to "warm" when it's finished. No more overcooking meals!!

    YouTube review · Amazon Kitchen Review (quoting a customer review) · 2018-08 · watch the original ↗

  • The directions say "FOR COOK AND CARRY MODELS, DO NOT LOCK THE LID WHEN COOKING

    YouTube comment · CricketNewJersey · 2024-10 · watch the original ↗

  • Avoid digital. They have a break point!

    Reddit comment · u/Sixinchesaround84 · r/BuyItForLife · 2025-11-01 · read the original ↗

  • The manual models are nearly immortal

    Reddit comment · u/CampaignPurple649 · r/BuyItForLife · 2025-11-01 · read the original ↗

  • Used these 4 years didgetal is just onemore thing 2 break plus manual last 8+years keep it simple

    YouTube comment · AndyGenova-jr9ol · 2023-08 · watch the original ↗

  • I'm not happy with mine. It's too small and doesn't heat /cook that well. I was thinking about getting the 3rd one, Crockpot 7qt manual because it always make the top 5 list, but like you I do like the digital ones better.

    YouTube comment · 211sweetypie · 2023-08 · watch the original ↗

  • It's funny how a Crock-Pot didn't even win the best Crock-Pot competition.

    YouTube comment · Pwn3dbyth3n00b · 2016-12 · watch the original ↗

  • Bought a new 8qt crock pot. Cooked an 8lb pork butt on LOW for pulled pork, done in less than 8 hours. Cooked 4 lbs of chicken breast on LOW for pulled chicken, done in less then 2.5 hours. I expected both to take at least 50% longer.

    Reddit post · u/Smooth_Fill888 · r/Cooking · 2026-07-16 · read the original ↗

  • I've had the same problem with two other crock pots I've purchased recently. It's like the new "low" is high and high is super high.

    Reddit comment · u/Hurricane_Ditka_34 · r/Cooking · 2026-07-16 · read the original ↗

3
Best value with a probe

Hamilton Beach Set 'n Forget

6-Quart, with built-in meat probe

Illustration of Hamilton Beach Set 'n Forget Illustration of the product
Hamilton Beach Set 'n Forget — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Capacity
6 qt
Controls
Digital programmable with meat probe, locking lid

Why it ranks here. The cheaper programmable cooker with a trick the Crock-Pot lacks: a meat probe that ends the guessing, plus the same locking travel lid. One owner makes yogurt and Japanese natto on Keep Warm because it holds the perfect fermentation temperature, and chicken soup and turkey legs always come out great for another.

The trade is build quality. The display's front is a sticker that started peeling within a year for one owner, and by two and a half years the lights had gone out and the display was useless. A couple of new units smelled of burnt plastic on first use, and one commenter's jab is that the company hires marketers rather than engineers.

What owners like

  • Meat probe at a budget price
  • Locking lid
  • Ferments yogurt

What owners complain about

  • Display sticker peels, lights die
  • Burnt-plastic smell for some
  • Weaker build

What I like the most about the Hamilton Beach slow cooker is it can also be used to make yogurt and fermented soybeans (Japanese natto) by selecting the keep warm option. It maintains the perfect fermentation temperature.— YouTube comment · dustyrhodes6798 · 2012-12

5 positive · 1 mixed · 3 negative · 9 voices · ✓ all 9 linked to source

Read all 9 quotes (9 voices)
  • I have a Hamilton Beach Slow Cooker and I have not had any issues with it. It actually works quite well, I've made Chicken and Rice soup and also I've cooked Turkey Legs and they always came out great.

    YouTube comment · KaneshaAndrews · 2016-12 · watch the original ↗

  • Purchased this product from a local store in May 2016. Within the first year the plastic front (on the digital display) which turns out is just a big sticker, started peeling away from the unit. Then soon after the one year warranty ended the lights on the digital display began blinking out. Now 2.5 years in, I can't see the lights at all - so the digital display is useless. I'm very disappointed in the quality of this crockpot.

    YouTube comment · thepratts3489 · 2012-12 · watch the original ↗

  • I started mine and for some reason after the machine started smelling like burnt plastic why?

    YouTube comment · kenny9nails · 2012-12 · watch the original ↗

  • What I like the most about the Hamilton Beach slow cooker is it can also be used to make yogurt and fermented soybeans (Japanese natto) by selecting the keep warm option. It maintains the perfect fermentation temperature.

    YouTube comment · dustyrhodes6798 · 2012-12 · watch the original ↗

  • From what I understand Kitchenaid hires a heck of a lot of engineers who are interested in performance, whereas the other companies (I'm looking at you Hamilton Beach) hire a lot of marketing dweebs to try and 'push' whatever rumbles off their assembly line.

    YouTube comment · Hypatia4242 · 2016-12 · watch the original ↗

  • I love my Hamilton Beach Stow-n-go slow cooker. We make chili or spaghetti for larger crowds.

    YouTube comment · gaye-leapleiman7593 · 2023-08 · watch the original ↗

  • I think I’m going to get the Hamilton Beach digital, slow cooker with the lock lid and thermometer! I don’t think you can go wrong with that one, especially after your review.

    YouTube comment · juliekoester7776 · 2023-08 · watch the original ↗

  • My Hamilton slow cooker says lid and insert are top rack only for dishwasher. Lid fits in top rack. The black insert does not. Will it be okay bottom rack? I hate handwashing when I don’t have to.

    Reddit post · u/Ok-Panda3367 · r/Cooking · 2026-07-19 · read the original ↗

  • I just ordered the Hamilton Beach Defrost & Go Programmable Slow Cooker, Temperature Probe, 6 Quart Capacity and I can’t wait to get it. Thank you your video tells me I made the right purchase.

    YouTube comment · myazstar · 2024-07 · watch the original ↗

4
Most proven long-term

Crock-Pot 7-Qt Manual

Dial control, no digital parts

Illustration of Crock-Pot 7-Qt Manual Illustration of the product
Crock-Pot 7-Qt Manual — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Capacity
7 qt
Controls
Manual dial, no timer

Why it ranks here. What r/BuyItForLife tells you to buy: a pot, a heating base and one dial, with nothing digital to fail. One owner's 1970s Rival was her grandmother's and is making carnitas tonight, another's 1997 wedding gift outlasted the marriage, a family uses theirs slightly more than the oven, and thrift stores sell them for pocket change. Seven quarts fits a whole chicken or a rack of ribs.

There is no timer or auto-shutoff, so food sits on High if you are late home, and the knob can wear out after years of heavy use. It does one job with no searing, probe or programming, and owners who want that one job say buy this and nothing else.

What owners like

  • Decades on one dial
  • Fits a whole chicken
  • Very cheap

What owners complain about

  • No timer or shutoff
  • Knob wears eventually
  • Does one thing

Got this crockpot for a wedding gift in 1997. My marriage didn't last, but the crockpot is still going strong - and it has never cheated on me!— Reddit post · u/katmai_novarupta · r/BuyItForLife · 2025-07-26

7 positive · 7 voices · ✓ all 7 linked to source

Read all 7 quotes (7 voices)
  • Go to a thrift shop. Simple knob controls only

    Reddit comment · u/nykylie12 · r/BuyItForLife · 2025-11-01 · read the original ↗

  • I just have a basic 7 qt Crock Pot that I bought on sale. It has one knob and I've never cooked a bad meal in it. $25

    YouTube comment · queenrocks77 · 2016-12 · watch the original ↗

  • We have a good old-fashioned Crock Pot oval about 6 quarts with the dial for Off Low High and Warm and it works fine for us. To keep track of cooking time we just set a timer. We are actually using it slightly more often than our oven for meals.

    YouTube comment · davinalloydbond · 2016-12 · watch the original ↗

  • i get all of my slow cookers at the thrift store for close to $10.

    YouTube comment · vitalsteve1 · 2016-12 · watch the original ↗

  • Rival Brand Crockpot from the 1970s. Was my Grandma's and now it is mine. Currently making carnitas for tacos tonight

    Reddit post · u/AaronfromKY · r/BuyItForLife · 2024-01-16 · read the original ↗

  • Got this crockpot for a wedding gift in 1997. My marriage didn't last, but the crockpot is still going strong - and it has never cheated on me!

    Reddit post · u/katmai_novarupta · r/BuyItForLife · 2025-07-26 · read the original ↗

  • Im okay with manual

    YouTube comment · PACLUWTV · 2023-08 · watch the original ↗

Frequently asked questions

What size slow cooker do I need?

Three to four quarts for one or two people, six for a family, seven or eight for a whole chicken or a potluck batch.

Why does my new slow cooker cook faster and hotter than the old one?

Manufacturers raised the temperatures for food safety, so old recipe times are too long.

Digital programmable or manual dial?

A dial has fewer parts to break and lasts decades, while digital adds a timer and auto-warm but the display is the usual failure point.

Can a slow cooker replace a pressure cooker?

No, they work in opposite ways, and combo units do both a little worse than dedicated appliances.

How this ranking was made

Every quote on this page links to the post or video it came from, so you can read it in context. ✓ 38 quotes from 38 distinct voices.