vilagai

✓ 43 sourced quotes

Ranked by evidence

Best instant-read thermometers

I dropped my thermapen into a pot of 350° frying oil for about 30 seconds as I scrambled to get my dirty tongs from the dishwasher. That was 3 years ago and it still works like the day I bought it.— YouTube comment · @GlovedManus · 2025-07-17 · on the #1 pick, Thermapen ONE

  1. 1 Thermapen ONEBest overall 11 quotes
  2. 2 ThermoPro TP19Best value 10 quotes
  3. 3 Javelin PRO DuoBest mid-range 9 quotes
  4. 4 Alpha Grillers Instant ReadCheapest 7 quotes
  5. 5 ThermoPop 2Best cheap ThermoWorks 6 quotes
1
Best overall

Thermapen ONE

Illustration of Thermapen ONE Illustration of the product
Thermapen ONE — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Price
$60 to $109
Read time
About 1 second

Why it ranks here. The Thermapen ONE wins every side-by-side test for a reason: a true one-second read, tight accuracy, and a body that comes out of the deep fryer working. It ranks first because pros and owners of many years say so. Its one fault is the $109 list price, which nobody who waits for a sale pays.

'I dropped my thermapen into a pot of 350° frying oil for about 30 seconds', says one owner. 'That was 3 years ago and it still works like the day I bought it'. A professional cook did the same: 'I once dropped it into the deep fryer. Grabbed tongs, pulled it out- no damage'. The speed changes habits: 'Literally 1 second update has made actually checking temps convenient', and one owner has 'purchased them as gifts for half of my family'. A former cheap-thermometer owner says it is 'in a completely different category of quality'. When an original Thermapen stopped working after years, 'They repaired it for free and sent it back'. On price: 'anyone who would pay that is not paying attention', since 'They ALWAYS have some sort of "special" going on'. The gripes are small: no built-in magnet, and a probe that could swing further for left-handers.

What owners like

  • 'Literally 1 second update has made actually checking temps convenient'
  • Dropped in 350-degree oil for 30 seconds, and three years later 'it still works like the day I bought it'
  • Five-year warranty, and an old one 'repaired it for free and sent it back'

What owners complain about

  • $109 list; 'anyone who would pay that is not paying attention' to the sales
  • No magnet without a separate sleeve, and awkward for left-handers

I dropped my thermapen into a pot of 350° frying oil for about 30 seconds as I scrambled to get my dirty tongs from the dishwasher. That was 3 years ago and it still works like the day I bought it.— YouTube comment · @GlovedManus · 2025-07-17

10 positive · 1 mixed · 11 voices · ✓ all 11 linked to source

Read all 11 quotes (11 voices)
  • People can rationalize whatever their choice is from now to near forever, but there's a reason that the Thermopen one is top rated by more professional cooking people than any other. While you are technically correct that their LIST price is $109 anyone who would pay that is not paying attention. They ALWAYS have some sort of "special" going on pricing and the typical average over time allows you to purchase one in the $60-75 range depending on your patience level. Still not cheap but if value is important it's very competitive for a top of the heap performer.

    YouTube comment · @rodderbob · 2025-07-17 · watch the original ↗

  • I've had the Thermopen One for a few years now and the biggest thing is that it makes you a healthier cook. Getting temps on a grill or in a smoker is a pain when your thermometer takes 8-10 seconds. Literally 1 second update has made actually checking temps convenient. I've now purchased them as gifts for half of my family.

    YouTube comment · @iker42 · 2025-07-17 · watch the original ↗

  • I dropped my thermapen into a pot of 350° frying oil for about 30 seconds as I scrambled to get my dirty tongs from the dishwasher. That was 3 years ago and it still works like the day I bought it.

    YouTube comment · @GlovedManus · 2025-07-17 · watch the original ↗

  • I used a classic Thermapen for years and didn't hesitate to buy the Thermapen One when it came out. I've used the others -- even bought them for people who had no instant read thermometer. They work, but for something I use and rely upon every damned day, it's a no-brainer to pay for the best. Words can't capture how much the small differences make life easier.

    YouTube comment · @quakerwildcat · 2025-07-17 · watch the original ↗

  • I've been using the Thermapen One for a year now and I'm really happy with it's performance. Readings are quick and accurate. Here in the UK it's a favourite in commercial kitchens. If there's anything I'd like to see improved on it if would be a the ability to use it left handed (by allowing the probe to swing further) and possibly a temperature lock but I can live without those features.

    YouTube comment · @LairdDavidson · 2025-07-17 · watch the original ↗

  • Bought a cheapo one on Amazon and it was ok the first couple months but then just started acting up. Went and got a thermapen mk4 and not looking back. It’s super frustrating when you need it to work and it doesn’t so I’d say with the amount I use it for me it’s a no brainer. If you are planning on using it a lot it’s worth the investment, definitely in a completely different category of quality

    Reddit comment · u/SmokeyWolf117 · r/BBQ · 2021-01-14 · read the original ↗

  • I work in a professional kitchen and I only use a Thermapen. Spot on calibration, fast readings, and durable. I once dropped it into the deep fryer. Grabbed tongs, pulled it out- no damage.

    Reddit comment · u/justanothermaroon · r/BBQ · 2019-08-05 · read the original ↗

  • I still have the Thermapen original which is very slow but still good enough for me. I had to send it in a few years ago because it stopped working. They repaired it for free and sent it back. Since then, the battery door has broken. I simply taped it down and it is still going strong. However, if I ever replaced this, I would go for whatever is the top-of-the-line at the time. Then that one should take me to end of my time here on earth!

    YouTube comment · @gosman949 · 2025-08-09 · watch the original ↗

  • I have the Thermapen One and it's great, but it still irritates me that I had to buy the magnetic sleeve for it . . . so I think it's a huge plus that the Sizzle now includes a magnet.

    YouTube comment · @MadPick · 2025-08-09 · watch the original ↗

  • Love my Thermapen!

    YouTube comment · highcountryhay · 2021-06-24 · watch the original ↗

  • ThermoWorks Thermapen One (WINNER)

    YouTube review · One reviewer (Prudent Reviews test) · 2025-07-17 · watch the original ↗

2
Best value

ThermoPro TP19

TP19 and TP19H are the same thermometer in different finishes

Illustration of ThermoPro TP19 Illustration of the product
ThermoPro TP19 — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Price
$13 to $30
Read time
2 to 4 seconds

Why it ranks here. The TP19 is the $13 to $30 thermometer with a big red display, a magnet and a waterproof rating, reading a few seconds behind the Thermapen. It ranks second on value. It ranks below the Thermapen because a run of owners had theirs die inside a year.

'its miles ahead of my shitty one i got at walmart', says a new owner: 'The display is nice, it reads fast and is accurate', and 'For 16 its a steal'. Another loves 'the red LED lighted numbers' he 'can see the temps on the brightest of days outside', and both his ThermoPros 'were both calibrated 100% correct right straight out of the box'. A grill regular finds it 'about on par with the Javelin Pro. It is not as high quality as the Thermapen, but it also costs a 1/4 as much'. One owner sees 'no use to spend the high $$$ for ThermoWorks stuff'. Then the failures: 'Mine is in the trash. It broke after 6 months'; another 'died right after a year'; a third: 'This thing is NOT water proof. Mine got ruined the first time cleaning it'. The three-year warranty and quick replacements soften that.

What owners like

  • 'The display is nice, it reads fast and is accurate', and 'For 16 its a steal'
  • 'about on par with the Javelin Pro' at a quarter of the Thermapen's price
  • Red digits you 'can see the temps on the brightest of days outside', plus a magnet

What owners complain about

  • 'It broke after 6 months' for one owner, 'died right after a year' for another
  • 'This thing is NOT water proof' for one, despite the rating

I just got the thermpro tp19h and its miles ahead of my shitty one i got at walmart. The display is nice, it reads fast and is accurate.. my old one took like 5+ seconds to get a final temp and its annoying since the probe is fixed so the display can be difficult to read when working in a hot environment. For 16 its a steal— YouTube comment · @Mixwell1983 · 2021-05-27

5 positive · 5 negative · 10 voices · ✓ all 10 linked to source

Read all 10 quotes (10 voices)
  • If you want a fast handheld thermometer, i think the Thermo Pro TP-19 is a great option without spending a ton... The TP-19 seems to be pretty well made, about on par with the Javelin Pro. It is not as high quality as the Thermapen, but it also costs a 1/4 as much.

    Reddit comment · u/TheEmfinger · r/BBQ · 2019-08-05 · read the original ↗

  • A really GOOD honest review Dave! Thank you! I just recently bought the TP25 (4 probe) and the TP19 in the red handle color. Absolutely love both of them! I especially love the red LED lighted numbers in the TP19. I can see the temps on the brightest of days outside. Tested both of mine (Hot/Cold) and they were both calibrated 100% correct right straight out of the box.

    YouTube comment · @ZEROPERCENT-1 · 2021-05-27 · watch the original ↗

  • I just got the thermpro tp19h and its miles ahead of my shitty one i got at walmart. The display is nice, it reads fast and is accurate.. my old one took like 5+ seconds to get a final temp and its annoying since the probe is fixed so the display can be difficult to read when working in a hot environment. For 16 its a steal

    YouTube comment · @Mixwell1983 · 2021-05-27 · watch the original ↗

  • I have the TP19, red one with red digital numbers and I like that one a lot! Super fast, water proof, and I paid 25 dollars for it, although I think it costs 30 dollars now.

    YouTube comment · @dkidl2000 · 2021-05-27 · watch the original ↗

  • Mine is in the trash. It broke after 6 months

    YouTube comment · @jw4295 · 2021-05-27 · watch the original ↗

  • This thing is NOT water proof. Mine got ruined the first time cleaning it after first use.

    YouTube comment · @CagoEman23 · 2021-05-27 · watch the original ↗

  • I bought one of these and it died right after a year….total piece of junk. Now own a thermapen one and won’t bother with anymore cheap knockoffs.

    YouTube comment · @BeamerTime354 · 2021-05-27 · watch the original ↗

  • Honestly I've been so pleased with my ThermoPro thermometers (the Lightning and the TP19) I see no use to spend the high $$$ for ThermoWorks stuff... despite every possible abuse I can heap on both neither has let me down and both are blazing fast though the Lightning is REALLY REALLY fast. Blink of an eye fast

    YouTube comment · @lmfinato · 2025-08-09 · watch the original ↗

  • My therma pro broke after just a year. I will be upgrading, thank you for the recommendation!

    YouTube comment · @icetruckk · 2025-07-17 · watch the original ↗

  • I had to return a ThermoPro TP710 earlier this year--it's a combo instant read with a probe, 4.6 stars on Amazon with 1000+ reviews, what could go wrong? The probe feature automatically shuts off after 10 minutes, so it's worthless for using it in the oven. This is by design. I've got extreme doubts about this brand. Stay away!

    YouTube comment · @AP55611 · 2025-07-17 · watch the original ↗

3
Best mid-range

Javelin PRO Duo

Illustration of Javelin PRO Duo Illustration of the product
Javelin PRO Duo — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Price
$35 to $55
Read time
About 3 seconds

Why it ranks here. The Javelin PRO Duo looks like a Thermapen at half the price, with a rotating screen, a magnet and a second sensor for ambient temperature. It ranks third because it ships in Celsius with no obvious way to change it, its battery door fights you, and a few owners found Lavatools' support useless.

'I have a Thermapen One and it's great but I also bought a LavaTools Javalin Pro Duo and it's damn near as good for half the price', says one owner. It is another's 'favorite mid-range choice' among several. Owners praise 'Quick reads, the screen rotates so it's always right-side-up', and the fridge magnet. The Celsius default trips people: 'The instruction for switching to Celsius was a lifesaver!', and a repeat buyer needed a video to 'save dinner tonight'. The battery: 'The battery is locked in place with no give', and the manual says to remove it 'carefully'. One owner's hinge 'broke as it's kind of weak'. And one grill regular says to 'skip the Lavatools Javelin Pro': 'Their customer service is useless and the unit has no waterproofing really'.

What owners like

  • 'damn near as good for half the price' of a Thermapen, from an owner of both
  • 'the screen rotates so it's always right-side-up', with a magnet and an ambient sensor

What owners complain about

  • Ships in Celsius; owners need a video to switch it
  • 'The battery is locked in place with no give', and a hinge that 'broke as it's kind of weak'
  • 'Their customer service is useless and the unit has no waterproofing really', for one owner

I have a Thermapen One and it’s great but I also bought a LavaTools Javalin Pro Duo and it’s damn near as good for half the price but I never see to many videos on it.— YouTube comment · @polsok44 · 2025-08-09

4 positive · 3 mixed · 2 negative · 9 voices · ✓ all 9 linked to source

Read all 9 quotes (9 voices)
  • I’m glad you liked the Javelin Pro. I’ve had several instant thermometers, and this is my favorite mid-range choice, too. I store it in a drawer, but stick it on my stainless range hood when I know I’m going to be using it.

    YouTube comment · @shelaughs185 · 2025-07-17 · watch the original ↗

  • I have a Thermapen One and it’s great but I also bought a LavaTools Javalin Pro Duo and it’s damn near as good for half the price but I never see to many videos on it.

    YouTube comment · @polsok44 · 2025-08-09 · watch the original ↗

  • The instruction for switching to Celsius was a lifesaver! Thank you

    YouTube comment · @catpawprints1 · 2020-09-07 · watch the original ↗

  • I just bought a second one of these and threw the box away before I had used it. Since this was my second purchase, I wasn't expecting any problems. This one came in Celsius and I needed Fahrenheit. Thankfully your video helped save dinner tonight lol.

    YouTube comment · @GibsonLP07 · 2020-09-07 · watch the original ↗

  • I bought one of these several years ago, but all of a sudden it didn't seem like it couldn't read temperatures... Up until now, i'ts been great. Quick reads, the screen rotates so it's always right-side-up, and I can store it on the fridge with the built in magnet on the back. It's been great for several years. But I'm cooking some chicken breast right at this moment, and when I pulled the javelin off the fridge to measure the temp, I realized it wasn't working.

    YouTube comment · @bmid2ton2 · 2020-09-07 · watch the original ↗

  • My only real advice is to skip the Lavatools Javelin Pro. At $50+ it offers up nothing to the table. Their customer service is useless and the unit has no waterproofing really, which to me is important for a kitchen thermometer. It also seems to do nothing better than the TP-19 for double the cost.

    Reddit comment · u/TheEmfinger · r/BBQ · 2019-08-05 · read the original ↗

  • It's a good product but I've had to warranty mine because the piece that holds the probe on the hinge broke as it's kind of weak. So now I am careful to open it close to the hinge to reduce stress on the housing

    Reddit comment · u/garfield1979 · r/BBQ · 2015-12-18 · read the original ↗

  • I've been using the standard Javelin for a few months now and so far its been great.

    Reddit comment · u/dragonzim · r/BBQ · 2015-12-18 · read the original ↗

  • 6 years later I'm facing the same issue. The battery is locked in place with no give, a small metal tab holding it in and doesn't want to move. HOW THE HELL do we take this out. According to the manual, we take it out "carefully". Very helpful indeed.

    Reddit comment · u/syntax1976 · r/BBQ · 2024-12-04 · read the original ↗

4
Cheapest

Alpha Grillers Instant Read

The same thermometer sells under many names

Illustration of Alpha Grillers Instant Read Illustration of the product
Alpha Grillers Instant Read — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Price
$6 to $15
Read time
1 to 2 seconds

Why it ranks here. The Alpha Grillers is the $6 to $15 generic thermometer sold under a dozen names, and Amazon's bestseller: a two-second read, waterproof, a degree or two off. It ranks fourth because its owners treat it as disposable and say so, and quality varies by batch.

'At $10 there's zero reason not to have one. Pull it out, get your read in 2 seconds, done', says one owner. It is 'a generic thermometer that is sold under more than a dozen brand names', notes another, who paid $6.11 years ago: 'For a home cook, 1 or 2 degrees inaccurate is not a big deal, no reason to pay $50 or more'. When one owner's died, 'I just threw it away and got another Alpha Grillers', because 'And $10 vs $80? Fuhggetaboutit!'. In one test it 'was low by 1-2F, consistently and handled great when dropped or submerged'. One commenter is unimpressed: 'I literally just bought the same rebranded chinese crap for $5'. Which is also the point.

What owners like

  • 'At $10 there's zero reason not to have one'
  • 'low by 1-2F, consistently and handled great when dropped or submerged'

What owners complain about

  • 'the same rebranded chinese crap for $5', so batches vary
  • Runs a degree or two low, and lacks the magnet, backlight and rotation of dearer models

At $10 there's zero reason not to have one. Pull it out, get your read in 2 seconds, done. No more cutting into your steak to check. Waterproof too so you're not babying it around the grill.— Reddit post · u/Acrobatic_Inside3173 · r/BBQ · 2026-03-17

6 positive · 1 mixed · 7 voices · ✓ all 7 linked to source

Read all 7 quotes (7 voices)
  • The AlphaGrillers is a generic thermometer that is sold under more than a dozen brand names. We got one a few years ago for $6.11. Amazon has them as low as $7 now (July 2025). For a home cook, 1 or 2 degrees inaccurate is not a big deal, no reason to pay $50 or more. All of these are much more accurate than the old mechanical thermometers.

    YouTube comment · @Fred2-123 · 2025-07-17 · watch the original ↗

  • I am glad I did not buy a thermopen when my instant read thermometer stopped working — I just threw it away and got another Alpha Grillers. There is nothing I do that being 1 degree off will make a difference. And $10 vs $80? Fuhggetaboutit!

    YouTube comment · @John-wx2ce · 2025-07-17 · watch the original ↗

  • The alphapro was low by 1-2F, consistently and handled great when dropped or submerged, that's definitely the best value pick when you consider it's almost 1/4 of the best one.

    YouTube comment · @egolono10 · 2025-07-17 · watch the original ↗

  • You're kidding right? I literally just bought the same rebranded chinese crap for $5, there are so many of these... At cheaper price points....

    Reddit comment · u/MarzipanMoney7441 · r/BBQ · 2026-03-17 · read the original ↗

  • At $10 there's zero reason not to have one. Pull it out, get your read in 2 seconds, done. No more cutting into your steak to check. Waterproof too so you're not babying it around the grill.

    Reddit post · u/Acrobatic_Inside3173 · r/BBQ · 2026-03-17 · read the original ↗

  • Greatly appreciated review

    YouTube comment · @waltercyran3720 · 2024-01-09 · watch the original ↗

  • thanks for the vid, very helpful

    YouTube comment · @MichaelMozart108 · 2024-01-09 · watch the original ↗

5
Best cheap ThermoWorks

ThermoPop 2

Now fully waterproof

Illustration of ThermoPop 2 Illustration of the product
ThermoPop 2 — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Price
$20 to $35
Read time
2 to 3 seconds

Why it ranks here. The ThermoPop 2 is the small Thermapen: ThermoWorks accuracy and build at $20 to $35, reading in two to three seconds. It ranks fifth only because it is a step slower with a simpler screen, and ThermoWorks does not sell it on Amazon itself.

'I have both the Thermoworks Thermapen ($80) and the Thermoworks Thermopop ($34)', says one owner. 'The Thermapen is a little faster but if I had to do it over I would just buy the Thermopop. It is fast enough and built like a tank'. Another: 'ThermoWorks Pop is the way to go. Very fast (almost as quick as the Thermapen), excellent quality'. A third chose it for 'Much better price vs the pen. Works great'. An owner of the first version is 'happy with it' for frying. Next to the Thermapen ONE, one viewer 'didn't think it made a whole lot of sense', which is the honest case against it. On Amazon it comes only from third-party sellers, which worries some buyers about fakes.

What owners like

  • 'if I had to do it over I would just buy the Thermopop. It is fast enough and built like a tank'
  • 'almost as quick as the Thermapen', at a third of the price

What owners complain about

  • Two to three seconds against the Thermapen's one, with a smaller screen
  • Not sold by ThermoWorks on Amazon, only by third parties

I have both the Thermoworks Thermapen ($80) and the Thermoworks Thermopop ($34). The Thermapen is a little faster but if I had to do it over I would just buy the Thermopop. It is fast enough and built like a tank. Not that I have had any issues with either. I would recommend Thermoworks though.— Reddit comment · u/running_chef · r/BBQ · 2021-01-14

4 positive · 1 mixed · 1 neutral · 6 voices · ✓ all 6 linked to source

Read all 6 quotes (6 voices)
  • I have both the Thermoworks Thermapen ($80) and the Thermoworks Thermopop ($34). The Thermapen is a little faster but if I had to do it over I would just buy the Thermopop. It is fast enough and built like a tank. Not that I have had any issues with either. I would recommend Thermoworks though.

    Reddit comment · u/running_chef · r/BBQ · 2021-01-14 · read the original ↗

  • ThermoWorks Pop is the way to go. Very fast (almost as quick as the Thermapen), excellent quality.

    Reddit comment · u/_MadSuburbanDad_ · r/BBQ · 2021-01-14 · read the original ↗

  • I'm going for say "you get what you pay for." And thermo works is a very reputable company. With that said, I bought the thermo pop. Much better price vs the pen. Works great.

    Reddit comment · u/Canadian_Couple · r/BBQ · 2015-12-18 · read the original ↗

  • I have Thermopop 1 and I'm happy with it, I mostly use it for frying

    YouTube comment · @father042 · 2025-07-17 · watch the original ↗

  • At first it looked kinda cute in the thumbnail. But when I saw it next to the One (and only), I didn't think it made a whole lot of sense. I really hope they make a keychain that is just as reliable as the One.

    YouTube comment · @soumynonareverse7807 · 2025-08-09 · watch the original ↗

  • We're putting the brand-new Thermoworks Sizzle instant-read thermometer to the test! In this first look, we compare it side-by-side with the ThermoPop 2 and Thermapen ONE to see how it compares in speed, usability, and price.

    YouTube review · The Barbecue Lab (video description) · 2025-08-09 · watch the original ↗

Frequently asked questions

Is a $100 Thermapen worth it over a $10 one?

Not for most home cooks. The Alpha Grillers and the ThermoPro read within a degree or two of it, which is close enough for dinner. People who use a thermometer every day, in restaurants and at barbecue competitions, say the speed, the toughness and the five-year warranty are worth it. And the Thermapen ONE sells for $60 to $80 on its frequent sales, not the $109 list price.

How fast should it read?

The Thermapen ONE takes about one second. The ThermoPop 2 and the Javelin take two to three. The cheap ones take two to five, depending on how hot or cold the food already is. Owners say the difference between one second and eight is the difference between checking temperatures and not bothering.

Are they really waterproof?

The Thermapen ONE and the ThermoPro TP19 claim full IP67 waterproofing; the Javelin is only water-resistant. Some owners of 'waterproof' cheap models still killed theirs in the wash. Wipe it dry rather than dunking it, whatever the box says.

How do I switch from Celsius to Fahrenheit?

Usually by holding a button while switching on, or by pulling the battery briefly. The Lavatools Javelin ships in Celsius and confuses more owners than any other model here. Check the manual before deciding it is broken.

How this ranking was made

Every quote on this page links to the post or video it came from, so you can read it in context. ✓ 43 quotes from 42 distinct voices.