vilagai

✓ 54 sourced quotes

Ranked by evidence

Best adjustable dumbbells

You keep saying "over time." I've owned mine for 16 years having bought it back in 2005. It's my main and only source of weight lifting, I use it 4 - 7 days a week and have had literally no issues and till today am so glad that I purchased it. It saves on over all price and space.— YouTube comment · JDemen82 · 2021-06-08 · on the #1 pick, Bowflex SelectTech 552

  1. 1 Bowflex SelectTech 552Best overall 13 quotes
  2. 2 NÜOBELLFeels most like a dumbbell 12 quotes
  3. 3 PowerBlock Elite / Pro EXPLongest lasting 11 quotes
  4. 4 Ironmaster Quick-LockMost drop-proof 10 quotes
  5. 5 FitRx SmartBell Quick-SelectCheapest, recalled 8 quotes
1
Best overall

Bowflex SelectTech 552

The 1090 goes to 90 pounds a hand

Illustration of Bowflex SelectTech 552 Illustration of the product
Bowflex SelectTech 552 — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Range
5 to 52.5 lb a hand, 2.5 lb steps
Adjustment
Dial; not for dropping

Why it ranks here. The SelectTech 552 is the adjustable dumbbell most people own and the one every other gets compared to: 5 to 52.5 pounds a hand in a dial, for $300 to $430, with owners at sixteen years of use. It ranks first on that record, with a recall and a rule attached: never drop it.

The longest report is the best one: 'I've owned mine for 16 years having bought it back in 2005', 'my main and only source of weight lifting', used four to seven days a week with 'literally no issues'. Another pair 'have been going strong for ~7 years' and their owner would have paid 'more than double for a full set'. The rules are strict: 'You just have to be gentle with them (no dropping)'. Owners who were not report that 'they always lock up if you don't treat them gingerly', plates that drop, and after twelve years 'plastic plates are falling and one of the dials at the end of dumbbell cracked'. The shape annoys too: the same 16 inches at 5 pounds, and ends that 'kind of dig into you' on the thighs before a press. A 2024 recall covers plates detaching, so check the serial number on a used pair.

What owners like

  • Sixteen years for one owner, 'my main and only source of weight lifting', with 'literally no issues'
  • A rack in a box, at less than half the price of fixed dumbbells
  • Smooth for years if you 'just have to be gentle with them (no dropping)'

What owners complain about

  • Dropped or knocked, 'they always lock up if you don't treat them gingerly', and after twelve years 'plastic plates are falling'
  • Sixteen inches long at every weight, and ends that 'kind of dig into you' on the thighs
  • A 2024 recall for plates detaching in use

You keep saying "over time." I've owned mine for 16 years having bought it back in 2005. It's my main and only source of weight lifting, I use it 4 - 7 days a week and have had literally no issues and till today am so glad that I purchased it. It saves on over all price and space.— YouTube comment · JDemen82 · 2021-06-08

5 positive · 6 mixed · 2 negative · 13 voices · ✓ all 13 linked to source

Read all 13 quotes (13 voices)
  • You keep saying "over time." I've owned mine for 16 years having bought it back in 2005. It's my main and only source of weight lifting, I use it 4 - 7 days a week and have had literally no issues and till today am so glad that I purchased it. It saves on over all price and space.

    YouTube comment · JDemen82 · 2021-06-08 · watch the original ↗

  • I have had these for several weeks and I have been really happy with them so far. I love being able to do a variety of workouts at home when I don't have time to make it to the gym. When paired with a basic bench, there are tons of different exercises and you can hit pretty much all major muscle groups. It is easy to adjust to your desired weight with the dials on each side. They slide in and out of the cradle smoothly. The only downside to this design vs the newer version, is that these are pretty wide. This does limit your range of motion with certain hand positions on certain exercises. Straight dumbbell press would be an example of this. I have to turn my hands slightly in order to bring them close enough together. Not a huge deal to me though. Really happy with this purchase and would definitely recommend.

    YouTube comment · stephanieking9242 · 2021-06-08 · watch the original ↗

  • One issue Coop didn't cover is that the ends aren't very comfortable when you're setting up for a press with them on your legs. They're not totally flat and aren't wide, so they kind of dig into you. They also don't feel great when you have them resting on your shoulders (for leg exercises) due to how the plates aren't uniform. All things you can get used to, so probably not a dealbreaker for most people.

    YouTube comment · kenz526 · 2021-06-08 · watch the original ↗

  • I've had these for ~10 years. At the time, there weren't many options. I've since upgraded to a full dumbbell rack. But, these guys are now in the office for a quick set during meetings. I don't regret the purchase, but there is so much more on the market these days.

    YouTube comment · Ringleader3rik · 2021-06-08 · watch the original ↗

  • Got the original Bowflex for 12 +yrs now... plastic plates are falling and one of the dials at the end of dumbbell cracked. I think it's about time to invest in a metal plate adjustable dumbbells with more weight.(so it will last longer). Nice video pal

    YouTube comment · marmonte6975 · 2022-06-03 · watch the original ↗

  • I received the 60 pound Bowflex weights as a Father’s Day gift a few years back and I swear by them. I have limited space, so a whole rack of dumbbells isn’t practical. I use them. My girlfriend uses them. They’re great!

    Reddit comment · u/Carpe-Bananum · r/homegym · 2026-04-26 · read the original ↗

  • I’ve been rockin my bowflex 552s for many years now. Never had any issues with them. No plates fall off (like the current recall). They have been solid. I just pick up heavier pairs of if I need more than 52.5lbs, but the 552s cover most of what I need. I use them almost daily.

    Reddit comment · u/7empestSpiralout · r/homegym · 2026-04-24 · read the original ↗

  • I have the (now recalled) bowflex 552s and I like them but I do find them to be cumbersome and clunky at lower weights. They remain the same length even at their lowest weights and I find for some exercises they are just tricky to work with due to their size.

    Reddit comment · u/Snackiesandcrafties · r/homegym · 2026-04-25 · read the original ↗

  • I have a Bowflex set. I think I paid around $300 and deal at the time was free adjustable bench with purchase. No ragrets, would have cost more than double for a full set with the same range and used much more space. You just have to be gentle with them (no dropping) but mine have been going strong for ~7 years now with regular use.

    Reddit comment · u/mark5hs · r/homegym · 2026-04-24 · read the original ↗

  • I’ve had the Bowflex Select tech forever. But they always lock up if you don’t treat them gingerly. I’ve had them drip plates too. Got tired of that so when i could finally afford it, i went old school

    Reddit comment · u/Lopsided_Primary_225 · r/homegym · 2026-08-25 · read the original ↗

  • I sold my Bowflex dumbells for $700 during Covid and bought new Ironmaster dumbbells. I was worried plastic adjustable Bowflex would eventually fail.

    Reddit comment · u/groshreez · r/homegym · 2026-06-02 · read the original ↗

  • I have the bowflex 1090s which cost $900 plus the cost of the stand. I do like the bowflex 1090s, my only gripe being that they are a a few inches longer than a standard dumbbell which makes some movements a little awkward

    Reddit comment · u/Professional_Pound80 · r/homegym · 2026-06-26 · read the original ↗

  • I've had these for years, the rubber on the handles is still nice. The dial isn't as smooth anymore and now takes some finesse to change sometimes.

    YouTube comment · boepeepsgarage · 2021-06-08 · watch the original ↗

2
Feels most like a dumbbell

NÜOBELL

The S5100 goes to 100 pounds a hand

Illustration of NÜOBELL Illustration of the product
NÜOBELL — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Range
5 to 80 lb a hand; 100 on the S5100
Adjustment
Twist, about 10 seconds; not for dropping

Why it ranks here. The Nuobell is the upgrade people make after their first adjustable set: it looks and feels like a real dumbbell, changes from 5 to 80 pounds in ten seconds, and owners who had PowerBlocks sold them. It ranks second because it cannot be dropped, and a few handles have died within months.

'how the nuö bell actually looks and feels like a real dumbbell' is the point, says an owner who bought a second pair of 80s to superset. One who 'was perfectly content with power block pros' tried Nuobells and 'Sold the powerblocks in no time'. A year of use, commercial use included, with 'no issues at all whatsoever'. The catches: 'bit of play between the plates', a grip that gets slippery so 'I have to use chalk', and the drop question. One owner's handle 'stopped working' after two months, 'Those things are garbage'; another puts the fear plainly: 'Being forced to pick between breaking your body, or breaking your dumbbell is not a situation I ever want to be in'. Sets run $600 to $1,000 with the stand.

What owners like

  • 'looks and feels like a real dumbbell', flat ends and all
  • Ten seconds from 5 to 80 pounds, in a compact cradle
  • Owners of both prefer it: 'Sold the powerblocks in no time'

What owners complain about

  • Not for dropping: 'breaking your body, or breaking your dumbbell' is the choice one owner fears
  • One handle 'stopped working' at two months
  • 'bit of play between the plates', and a grip slippery enough that 'I have to use chalk'

I love the Nuö Bell. I started off with a pair of 50’s and loved them so much that I bought a second pair of 80’s so I could super set without having to go back to the cradle. It was still cheaper than buying a full set of 5-80lbs dumbbells... The other advantage that wasn’t talked about nearly enough is how the nuö bell actually looks and feels like a real dumbbell.— YouTube comment · strongg3nes400 · 2021-12-07

7 positive · 3 mixed · 2 negative · 12 voices · ✓ all 12 linked to source

Read all 12 quotes (12 voices)
  • I love the Nuö Bell. I started off with a pair of 50’s and loved them so much that I bought a second pair of 80’s so I could super set without having to go back to the cradle. It was still cheaper than buying a full set of 5-80lbs dumbbells... The other advantage that wasn’t talked about nearly enough is how the nuö bell actually looks and feels like a real dumbbell.

    YouTube comment · strongg3nes400 · 2021-12-07 · watch the original ↗

  • I got these a few months back (I am from Europe). And they are really really great! You just need to handle them a bit more gently (as in, don't throw them on the floor, and put them back in the rack carefully). I am 100% satisfied. Perfect for the home gym.

    YouTube comment · m1ch4Lko · 2020-09-29 · watch the original ↗

  • Been using these for a year. They sell a kilo set/up to 20kgs and the 40kg ones are an add on. The plastic has held up through repetitive use with no issues at all whatsoever. No issues with the alignment/wear and tear and its still all in the proper place. Used commercially too

    YouTube comment · pauljantan3362 · 2020-09-29 · watch the original ↗

  • I have the same green 80lb. Nuobell set (with the stand), it's my favorite piece of gym equipment, I use it every day I work out. The minor annoyances are the bit of play between the plates when you're lifting and it's sometimes tricky to put them back in the cradle, especially with heavier weight.

    YouTube comment · NickSiekierski · 2021-12-07 · watch the original ↗

  • Dude, don't get rid of the powerblocks. My Nuobells lasted for two months before the handle stopped working. Those things are garbage.

    Reddit comment · u/GobiEats · r/homegym · 2026-07-01 · read the original ↗

  • I was perfectly content with power block pros, I thought. Then got a ridiculous deal on Nuobells, such that I could prob sell and break even if needed. Well, I like the nuobells much better. Sold the powerblocks in no time.

    Reddit comment · u/AndKAnd · r/homegym · 2026-07-01 · read the original ↗

  • I have the Nuobell 5lb - 80lb adjustable dumbbells. They’re really awesome with a few downsides. I found I needed a dumbbell rack for them otherwise it’s awkward to adjust/lift from the ground... And the grips on them are a little slippery so for anything heavier I have to use chalk. But otherwise they’re so easy to change quickly and feel really solid and natural. Like them better than the bowflex which I’ve previously had

    Reddit comment · u/verderese96 · r/homegym · 2026-04-30 · read the original ↗

  • I found that the adjustable dumbbells are awesome for small spaces. I have the Nuobell 5-80’s and love them. Saves me a ton of space.

    Reddit comment · u/StrangerEffective851 · r/homegym · 2026-06-30 · read the original ↗

  • Thats exactly the problem with nuobells. What if you must drop the dumbbell to avoid an injury? Being forced to pick between breaking your body, or breaking your dumbbell is not a situation I ever want to be in.

    Reddit comment · u/matttvk · r/homegym · 2026-07-03 · read the original ↗

  • Im super happy with with switch from nuobell to pepins (I found a pair of the originals, which are very similar to the reps). They feel so much more secure and when throwing around heavy weight, I'm not terrified of what happens if I have to drop them. Changing takes 2 seconds more.. but not a deal breaker for me

    Reddit comment · u/crazyascarl · r/homegym · 2026-07-01 · read the original ↗

  • Maybe just the honeymoon phase but absolutely loving my Nuobell S5100. Moved recently and sold my equipment so starting over, went from having 5 to 50lb set of dumbbells plus ironmaster 120s.

    Reddit comment · u/TacoTrader · r/homegym · 2026-09-04 · read the original ↗

  • First day impressions: It arrived in a waist high box... Each dumbbell was in its own foam box within the shipping box. Everything was secure and in good shape... The weight changing mechanism is really smooth and straight forward. Changing weight is really fast and easy. Though the handle is plastic, I don't think it will be breaking anytime soon.

    YouTube comment · MrGabrielallon · 2021-12-07 · watch the original ↗

3
Longest lasting

PowerBlock Elite / Pro EXP

US-made Elite, or the cheaper Pro EXP; kits to 50, 70 and 90 lb

Illustration of PowerBlock Elite / Pro EXP Illustration of the product
PowerBlock Elite / Pro EXP — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Range
5 to 50, 70 or 90 lb a hand by kit
Adjustment
Pin and cage; tolerates drops

Why it ranks here. PowerBlock invented the adjustable dumbbell, and its owners talk in decades: 1993, 1995, 2001. The pin and cage tolerates being set down hard and gives true 2.5-pound steps. It ranks third because the cage is uncomfortable for some, the pin breaks, and the US-made Elite has become expensive.

'I bought the Power Blocks when they first came out in 1993', says one owner, 'still in perfect shape'. Another has 'used and abused them for getting close to 30 years', and when his son dropped one and a clip casing broke, 'I super-glued it back on and it's fine now'. A 2001 pair has 'THOUSANDS of workouts' behind it. The 2.5-pound steps without magnetic plates keep one owner from switching to Nuobells. The complaints: the selector pin 'has broke 3 times now', replaced free each time; the weight rides on the outer rails, so 'you can feel a difference in how the weight is distributed'; and the cage, which sent one owner to Ironmaster: 'Don't underestimate the discomfort of the Powerblock cages!'. Reviewers call the Elite's price gouging.

What owners like

  • Decades: 'when they first came out in 1993' and 'still in perfect shape', another 'close to 30 years'
  • Takes a drop: a broken clip casing was 'super-glued it back on and it's fine now'
  • True 2.5-pound steps without magnetic plates

What owners complain about

  • 'Don't underestimate the discomfort of the Powerblock cages!'
  • The plastic selector pin 'has broke 3 times now' for one owner, free replacements each time
  • Weight on the outer rails, so 'you can feel a difference in how the weight is distributed', and a steep Elite price

I have the original Powerblock 90s (I think I bought them in 1995). I have absolutely used and abused them for getting close to 30 years now. They were a 1 time purchase that cost less than a year's gym membership... Just last year I had the plastic casing on the outside of one of the clips break when my son dropped them at the end of a set. I super-glued it back on and it's fine now, but even that didn't affect the usability. I can testify to Powerblock's durability.— YouTube comment · dariuswalker738 · 2021-12-07

6 positive · 2 mixed · 1 neutral · 2 negative · 11 voices · ✓ all 11 linked to source

Read all 11 quotes (11 voices)
  • I have the original Powerblock 90s (I think I bought them in 1995). I have absolutely used and abused them for getting close to 30 years now. They were a 1 time purchase that cost less than a year's gym membership... Just last year I had the plastic casing on the outside of one of the clips break when my son dropped them at the end of a set. I super-glued it back on and it's fine now, but even that didn't affect the usability. I can testify to Powerblock's durability.

    YouTube comment · dariuswalker738 · 2021-12-07 · watch the original ↗

  • I bought the Power Blocks when they first came out in 1993 . They’re about 50 lbs and they are still in perfect shape . No dumbbells are perfect but they’re a brilliant , sturdy design . Hard to beat .

    YouTube comment · brutus4013 · 2021-12-07 · watch the original ↗

  • I bought my powerblocks 90LB dumbbells back in 2003 and have had zero issues with them.

    YouTube comment · leftlimelight · 2021-12-07 · watch the original ↗

  • I've had my Powerblocks since 2001. THOUSANDS of workouts. Still going strong. Never had a problem with the cage design and quite like the square form factor (never had one roll off a bench).

    YouTube comment · brucec2787 · 2021-12-07 · watch the original ↗

  • I've had PowerBlocks for over a decade and they are still like new minus some missing paint in the corners of the plates. As of right now, I can't put that kind of trust in Nuobells. But the ONE thing that really keeps me with PowerBlocks is the 2.5lb increments, without having to use some kind of magnetic change plates.

    YouTube comment · d2mini · 2021-12-07 · watch the original ↗

  • I have the USA Elite Powerblocks up to 90lbs and I’m definitely a fan... Only down side that is reoccurring is that the plastic selector pin, it has broke 3 times now because it doesn’t want to slide right in and a prong brakes off (PowerBlock does replace them for free each time if you contact them) but they still work if you use time safely until you get a new one.

    YouTube comment · JustinRHerder · 2021-12-07 · watch the original ↗

  • I love the durability of my powerblocks but one thing not mentioned people should be aware of is that the weights are connected via those outside tubes, not the central handle. It may sound trivial but you can feel a difference in how the weight is distributed around your hand rather than through the central handle.

    YouTube comment · nailatiylluf · 2021-12-07 · watch the original ↗

  • Swapped my powerblocks for ironmasters this week and couldn't be happier. Don't underestimate the discomfort of the Powerblock cages!

    YouTube comment · Handl3sAreStupid · 2021-12-07 · watch the original ↗

  • Massive respect for calling out Powerblock price gouging (arguably). Always to glad to see unbiased reviews.

    YouTube comment · _purge9488 · 2021-12-07 · watch the original ↗

  • I really like the powerblocks and the weight increments isn't bad if I wanted to do them in 5lb increments but compared to the nuobells changing between them is much faster. I also don't find myself in positions to drop them... So far I've been really happy with them.

    Reddit comment · u/Expert-Run9476 · r/homegym · 2026-07-01 · read the original ↗

  • You can get Ironmaster Quick-lock 75lb set for $700. They will probably be the most durable, but weight changes will be slower... Powerblocks are also an option for quicker weight changes. $550 for the Pro 50s.

    Reddit comment · u/KeyLimeGuy69 · r/homegym · 2026-09-04 · read the original ↗

4
Most drop-proof

Ironmaster Quick-Lock

75 lb set, expandable to 120 or 165 lb a hand

Illustration of Ironmaster Quick-Lock Illustration of the product
Ironmaster Quick-Lock — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Range
2.5 to 75 lb a hand, up to 165 with kits
Adjustment
Screw collar; slowest, and drop-proof

Why it ranks here. Ironmaster is the all-metal one: screw-collar plates that can be dropped from a bench and loaded to 165 pounds a hand. Owners since 2014 report nothing broken. It ranks fourth for one reason, and every owner names it: changing the weight is slow.

'Have them since 2015, Never had a problem with them even with the 120lbs upgrade', and 'they can be dropped from bench height all day long'. Another has had them 'since 2014. Still working great'. For anything over 100 pounds one owner uses these and keeps PowerBlocks for the light work, 'Short of dropping 4 grand on regular dumbbells'. The rivalry is old and simple: 'If you wanted something most like real dumbbells that would last forever you got the Ironmasters. If you wanted quick changes you went with Powerblocks'. The slowness hurts supersets, and the length changes movements that bring the ends together, presses and deadlifts among them. About $700 to $870 for the 75-pound set with a stand.

What owners like

  • 'they can be dropped from bench height all day long', with no failures since 2014 and 2015
  • Loads to 165 pounds a hand, the heaviest here
  • The one 'that would last forever', in the old Ironmaster-versus-PowerBlock argument

What owners complain about

  • Slow to change, bad for supersets and drop sets
  • Longer than a solid dumbbell, which changes presses and deadlifts
  • $700 and up with a stand

Have them since 2015, Never had a problem with them even with the 120lbs upgrade. Yes they are slower to change, but they can be dropped from bench height all day long. Saves a ton of space also.— YouTube comment · johnsavior999 · 2023-10-19

8 positive · 2 mixed · 10 voices · ✓ all 10 linked to source

Read all 10 quotes (10 voices)
  • Iron master are some of the best feeling and most durable adjustable dumbbells. The changing weights is was kinda makes them annoying, but they make up with that with space savings.

    YouTube comment · carps_gym · 2023-10-19 · watch the original ↗

  • I’ve had mine since 2014. Still working great.

    YouTube comment · whatsyourexcuse927 · 2023-10-19 · watch the original ↗

  • I’ve had my set along with the kettlebell attachments for 5 years and they continue to impress me. I love them!

    YouTube comment · grimtrigg3r · 2023-10-19 · watch the original ↗

  • I just got the 75lb ironmaster quicklock set two months ago, and I love them. They are pretty quick to adjust once you get the hang of it, and they feel super solid. I was going back and forth between all kind of adjustable DB’s, and even thought about getting a full set, but I’m glad I went with these.

    YouTube comment · davids7211 · 2023-10-19 · watch the original ↗

  • Have them since 2015, Never had a problem with them even with the 120lbs upgrade. Yes they are slower to change, but they can be dropped from bench height all day long. Saves a ton of space also.

    YouTube comment · johnsavior999 · 2023-10-19 · watch the original ↗

  • Ironmaster vs Powerblock was probably the single biggest rivalry in home gyms for a couple of decades. But choosing was really more simple than people made it out to be. If you wanted something most like real dumbbells that would last forever you got the Ironmasters. If you wanted quick changes you went with Powerblocks.

    YouTube comment · plmn93 · 2023-10-19 · watch the original ↗

  • I did a moderate amount of homework on different adjustable dumbbell options and was persuaded away from the Ironmaster's in favor of quicker-adjusting ones... I did not realize quite how much the physical length of the dumbbells would influence movements of exercises that bring the ends of the dumbbells together, like db chest presses or even deadlifts... If I had thought a little further ahead... I think the Ironmaster's would've been a fine choice if not better choice.

    YouTube comment · Two_Names · 2023-10-19 · watch the original ↗

  • Bought the heavy handle set last year...love the ironmasters. I have some power blocks too (those are nice for the accessories 50lbs and under, the ironmasters are my go to for benching/RDLs/whatever I'm doing over 100lbs). Short of dropping 4 grand on regular dumbbells, this has been a pretty perfect solution for me.

    YouTube comment · TheHorrorGeek · 2023-10-19 · watch the original ↗

  • Ironmaster/eisenlinks: slower to adjust, but also durable AF. More budget-friendly as well.

    Reddit comment · u/Existing-Computer772 · r/homegym · 2026-05-09 · read the original ↗

  • If I were buying new today and wanted dumbbells that will last forever - ironmaster. If you want adj I just get reps options.

    Reddit comment · u/jiujitsuPhD · r/homegym · 2026-08-05 · read the original ↗

5
Cheapest, recalled

FitRx SmartBell Quick-Select

Also sold as a 10 to 90 lb version

Illustration of FitRx SmartBell Quick-Select Illustration of the product
FitRx SmartBell Quick-Select — thumbnail of a cited video review ▶ From a video review of this product Check price on Amazon →

affiliate link · goes to an Amazon search for this product

Range
5 to 52.5 lb a hand, 2.5 lb steps
Adjustment
Dial; the design behind the recall

Why it ranks here. The FitRx SmartBell is the $100 Bowflex lookalike from Walmart, and for many buyers it works. It ranks last because the US safety regulator recalled about 50,000 of them after plates fell off in use, and because owners describe dials jamming, bases cracking and plates loosening within months.

The happy owners are real: 'it's solid! Doesn't feel cheap or anything at all. Literally looks almost the same as the expensive bowflex version', and one verified with a magnet that his plates are cast iron. Then the failures. 'one of mine broke while I was overhead pressing, 3 of the plates fell out, luckily I was able to get my foot out of the way in time'. A base's guide piece 'broke on one of the bases after about 30 days', and the seller 'don't offer replacement parts'. One dial 'got stuck on the 50lb setting' for good; another owner's plates 'started falling off after like 4 months'. The recall counts 'more than 115 reports of weight plates dislodging during use' and injuries including broken toes. If you own one, register it for the free replacement parts. If you are shopping, spend the extra $200.

What owners like

  • About $100, and 'Literally looks almost the same as the expensive bowflex version'
  • Fast dial changes, and cast iron plates on some units
  • A year or more of trouble-free use for some owners

What owners complain about

  • Recalled: 'more than 115 reports of weight plates dislodging during use', with broken toes among the injuries
  • '3 of the plates fell out' mid-press for one owner, and plates 'started falling off after like 4 months' for another
  • A dial 'got stuck on the 50lb setting', a base guide that 'broke' at 30 days, and a seller with no spare parts

These are decent dumbbells but be careful, one of mine broke while I was overhead pressing, 3 of the plates fell out, luckily I was able to get my foot out of the way in time. It either lasted 1 and 1/2 years or 2 years... Also they can get stuck in the holders if they aren't put back in directly straight— YouTube comment · IntelligentleMANgief · 2023-11-28

3 positive · 5 negative · 8 voices · ✓ all 8 linked to source

Read all 8 quotes (8 voices)
  • I got one of these and i love it. Best dumbell ive had compared to the old school traditional ones. i love how fast it is to switch the weights out. replaces a whole rack of space. so nice

    YouTube comment · oswaldmensin5283 · 2023-11-28 · watch the original ↗

  • I bought one today to test it out before I bought a second one and I’ll tell u it’s solid! Doesn’t feel cheap or anything at all. Literally looks almost the same as the expensive bowflex version. The days I gotta go to work I use these for a full body workout rather than going to the gym because it’s super packed at 7 pm

    YouTube comment · kyb9206 · 2023-11-28 · watch the original ↗

  • These are decent dumbbells but be careful, one of mine broke while I was overhead pressing, 3 of the plates fell out, luckily I was able to get my foot out of the way in time. It either lasted 1 and 1/2 years or 2 years... Also they can get stuck in the holders if they aren't put back in directly straight

    YouTube comment · IntelligentleMANgief · 2023-11-28 · watch the original ↗

  • Thanks for making this video. I'm ordering the 10 to 90 ones for my home gym. EDIT AFTER USING THE 10-90s FOR A LITTLE OVER 30 DAYS: There is a plastic piece on the base that guides the weight onto the pin that allows you to switch weights. This plastic piece broke on one of the bases after about 30 days of use. I contacted the seller and they said they don't offer replacement parts and recommended I return it. I liked these at first but ended up returning them at my local Walmart a little over a month after getting them because of the issue with the plastic piece on the base.

    YouTube comment · Will_0001 · 2023-11-28 · watch the original ↗

  • The weight one one of the dumbbells started falling off after like 4 months

    YouTube comment · yohomiesfomthecurb5260 · 2023-11-28 · watch the original ↗

  • My fitRx adjustable dumb bell (5lb-52.5lb) got stuck and handle won't turn. I was able to release it from the base and I pushed the two white buttons on the end. That didn't work. I can't turn the handle to adjust the weight anymore. It got stuck on the 50lb setting, so when I pick it up it leaves two plates on the stand.

    YouTube comment · fryingpan4849 · 2023-11-28 · watch the original ↗

  • I have the same thing he has, the set that goes to 52.5 lbs. Mine are cast iron, not plastic. I verified that with a magnet... We agree on the quality construction, I think mine will last a long time too.

    YouTube comment · johnnysparkleface3096 · 2023-11-28 · watch the original ↗

  • The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission announced a recall of about 50,000 FitRx SmartBell dumbbells sold at Walmart after weight plates became dislodged, causing injuries including broken toes and bruises... There have been more than 115 reports of weight plates dislodging during use, with at least six injuries, including broken toes, bruises, contusions and lacerations.

    other · U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission · 2026-01-01 · read the original ↗

Frequently asked questions

What weight range should I buy?

Five to fifty pounds a hand covers most people. Heavy presses, rows and Romanian deadlifts outgrow 52.5 pounds within a year or two, which is when owners move to the 80 to 100 pound Nuobell, PowerBlock's heavier kits or Ironmaster's 120 and 165 pound add-ons.

Can I drop them?

Not the dial and twist designs. Bowflex, Nuobell and FitRx jam, crack or shed plates when dropped or set down hard. PowerBlock's pin and cage takes drops better, and Ironmaster's screw collars are the ones owners call drop-proof.

What do they cost?

About $100 for a FitRx pair to 52.5 pounds. $300 to $430 for the Bowflex 552. $400 to $700 and up for PowerBlock. $700 to $1,000 and more for Nuobell or Ironmaster with a stand.

Why were some recalled?

Bowflex SelectTech models and the FitRx SmartBell were recalled between 2024 and 2026 after plates came off the handle in use, breaking toes and cutting people. Check the CPSC list for your model and lot before buying new or used, and register for the free replacement parts.

How this ranking was made

Every quote on this page links to the post or video it came from, so you can read it in context. ✓ 54 quotes from 54 distinct voices.